Page 9901
1 Friday, 4 March 2005
2 [Open session]
3 [The accused entered court]
4 --- Upon commencing at 9.17 a.m.
5 JUDGE ORIE: Madam Registrar, would you please call the case.
6 THE REGISTRAR: Case number IT-00-39-T, the Prosecutor versus
7 Momcilo Krajisnik.
8 JUDGE ORIE: Thank you.
9 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, I've expressed my apologies privately.
10 I wonder if I could simply say that I am sorry that I was the cause of the
11 lateness in court this morning.
12 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Thank you very much, Mr. Stewart.
13 Ms. Hanson, first of all, I'd like to remind you that you're still
14 bound by the solemn declaration you've given at the beginning of your
15 testimony, and I was informed that you had, perhaps, an answer to one or
16 two of our questions.
17 Perhaps, Mr. Hannis, we should give we should give Ms. Hanson an
18 opportunity to give those answers.
19 WITNESS: DOROTHEA HANSON [Resumed]
20 THE WITNESS: Yes, thank you, Your Honour. You had inquired about
21 document P0008404 through P0008410. It's a report on the list of motor
22 vehicles at the logistics base in Cirkin Polje. That document had been
23 brought to my attention by Ewen Brown, who had written a report on the
24 military. Mr. Brown is no longer at the Tribunal, but I consulted his
25 report to see if he had more information about this document.
Page 9902
1 And what I see is he actually uses the next document -- a related
2 document which appears right next to it in the evidence, P0008411 through
3 P0008420, which is a related document, similarly from the logistics base
4 of the Crisis Staff in Cirkin Polje, dated the 16th of September, 1992. I
5 have a copy, and a copy of the translation, if it's of interest to you. I
6 noted it had been disclosed in this case on the 14th of December last
7 year.
8 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Do you have a copy for the Defence as well?
9 THE WITNESS: I have two copies. One has been highlighted. I was
10 just going to read the highlighted portion. I'm sorry. I don't have
11 three copies.
12 JUDGE ORIE: Perhaps we -- if one of the copies could be put on
13 the ELMO, and then the other copy be given to Mr. Stewart, and then
14 perhaps you could read, Ms. Hanson, the portion you thought relevant. I'm
15 afraid I forgot what the tab number was of the Cirkin Polje, and it might
16 be that -- because the long numbers, I can't memorise.
17 MR. HANNIS: I believe it's 178, Your Honour.
18 JUDGE ORIE: 178. And it certainly will be in the binder that's
19 on my desk downstairs. Yes, it starts with 179. Perhaps you can read it
20 and we'll check it later on the basis of the material.
21 THE WITNESS: Yes. As I said, this was dated on the 16th of
22 September, and it discusses in the first paragraph the setting up of the
23 logistics base, and in the second paragraph, the fact that it distributed
24 meals to army and police and prisoners in Omarska, Keraterm, and refugees
25 in Trnopolje. And it says that a report about the distribution of food
Page 9903
1 had been given to the Crisis Staff, the police, public security station,
2 and a copy of the report kept for the base's files.
3 This report also makes reference on the last page that --
4 JUDGE ORIE: Reporting, therefore, was mainly at the local level.
5 THE WITNESS: Yes. Simply, there's a reference on the last page
6 that they attach the list of motor vehicles from the logistics base of
7 Cirkin Polje, dated the 17th of June, 1992. And since these two documents
8 were found together, they appear next to each other in the evidence
9 record, they both indicate that they were found in the municipal building
10 in Prijedor. I take it that they were presented together. They were
11 found among materials of the Prijedor executive committee, dating from
12 October 1992, and the minutes from that session indicate that they
13 discussed the work of the logistics base in Cirkin Polje. So I take it
14 these material -- it would be logical that these materials were together
15 because they were being examined at the time by the executive committee.
16 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Therefore, we have no indication that this
17 material went higher up in the hierarchy than the Prijedor level.
18 THE WITNESS: No indication of that in these documents.
19 JUDGE ORIE: Thank you.
20 Then I wonder whether, Mr. Hannis, whether it's necessary to
21 include this document in evidence. It rather confirms that it was
22 reporting on the municipality level rather than ...
23 MR. HANNIS: I'm willing to stipulate that with Mr. Stewart, or we
24 can have this marked as an additional exhibit, whichever the Court
25 prefers.
Page 9904
1 JUDGE ORIE: At this moment at least, the Chamber ...
2 [Trial Chamber confers]
3 JUDGE ORIE: No, there's no specific wish of the Chamber to
4 receive that additional document in evidence.
5 MR. HANNIS: Thank you, Your Honour.
6 JUDGE ORIE: Please proceed.
7 Examined by Mr. Hannis: [Continued]
8 Q. Ms. Hanson, when we left off yesterday we were talking about the
9 treatment or the status of the non-Serbs in the municipalities vis-a-vis
10 the Crisis Staffs. I'm ready now to have you take a look at presentation
11 tab 203, which is master tab number 312, and we'll follow the same
12 procedure we've been doing of putting the B/C/S up in Sanction and the
13 English on the ELMO. And if you would direct us to the excerpt you wanted
14 to discuss. This is from the Sipovo municipality Crisis Staff meeting on
15 the 2nd of June.
16 A. Yes. I believe it's page 3 in the translation. I'm just going to
17 find it in the original. Yes, it's at the top of 02194122 in the B/C/S,
18 the very top line, and on page 3 in the English, indicating that the
19 Crisis Staff is discussing whether Muslims will live here in Sipovo, and
20 that they should -- whether the Crisis Staff should take a stand with
21 regard to Muslims. So it was, once again, an issue. One of the topics of
22 discussion, for Crisis Staffs was the status of non-Serbs.
23 Q. Thank you. Next I'd like to show you presentation tab 204, master
24 tab 311, from the Pale municipality.
25 A. This is an order of the Crisis Staff of Pale, dated the 7th of
Page 9905
1 May, 1992, ordering the -- that the following telephone numbers be
2 disconnected. All of these names on this list appear to be Muslim names.
3 And the last item, or last remark on the top of the second page, that 10
4 of those 15 numbers are to be given to Serbian Television Pale. It's a
5 small detail, but it indicates the kind of business with which Crisis
6 Staffs were occupied and the kind of measures they could take against
7 Muslims.
8 Q. Thank you.
9 MR. HANNIS: And, Your Honour, I would like to recall to you that
10 our crime-base witness from Pale testified about this document, and one of
11 the names on that list was his neighbour. Next, we're going to skip tabs
12 205 and 206, Your Honours and counsel. These are referred to in footnotes
13 in Ms. Hanson's report. And I want to go to tab 207, master tab 322.
14 Q. This is a document from the Vogosca Crisis Staff.
15 A. Yes. This is the conclusions of the Vogosca Crisis Staff, dated
16 the 17th of May, 1992. Under item 5, you would note that they are laying
17 off specifically Muslim and Croat staff from the hospital. This is also
18 an interesting document for a few other themes I've mentioned, if I could
19 briefly point out.
20 Item number 1, it's saying that they are -- the Crisis Staff will
21 issue an order for taking over the army barracks which are being placed
22 under the command of the Crisis Staff of the Serbian Assembly of Vogosca,
23 which is under the sole command of the Serb Republic of BiH. If you'll
24 note the date, the 17th of May, following the establishment of the VRS,
25 they're now asserting their control -- authority over the army barracks,
Page 9906
1 and it gives an indication of hierarchy. The barracks are under the
2 command of the Crisis Staff, which is under the command of the Serb
3 Republic.
4 Also, item 2, discussing the cleansing, ciscenje.
5 JUDGE HANOTEAU: Excuse me. In that 207, what does it mean that
6 number 2, "for the 'cleansing' of Svrake and other territories, one more
7 man is to be secured, apart from Mr. Borovcanin." What's the meaning of
8 it, please?
9 THE WITNESS: Well, the word cleansing, ciscenje, has a variety of
10 meanings, and it's not sufficiently clear from this sentence alone whether
11 they mean the military term of clearing the terrain after a battle or
12 mopping up the last resistance or the way we see it used in many other
13 cases as -- also known as ethnic cleansing. I would note in this case
14 that Svrake was a predominantly Muslim settlement, over 80 per cent
15 Muslim. And I see that, in fact, the revised translation didn't get into
16 my binder, so perhaps if we put up Mr. Hannis's translation, a little bit
17 of the confusion is removed because -- no, it didn't get revised. I'm
18 sorry, the --
19 JUDGE ORIE: On the computer -- under the computer evidence
20 button, you'll find the original.
21 THE WITNESS: Yes. I have the original here. I would just note
22 that the second sentence refers to the cleansing not of Svrake as it
23 appears in the translation but Semizovac, and if the interpreters can
24 confirm that's a reference to Semizovac not Svrake. So the first
25 sentence, they're talking about cleansing Svrake, getting one more person
Page 9907
1 for that. The second sentence, they're saying when to cleanse Semizovac
2 in the case of firing, any shooting.
3 What precisely they mean here by cleansing, this document alone
4 doesn't give an indication of what kind of cleansing.
5 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, may I observe, it's extremely helpful -
6 I don't suggest it's not helpful for Ms. Hanson to give an explanation and
7 go as far as she can - I can also observe that actually Ms. Hanson's use
8 of mopping up is entirely consistent with the discussion we had some weeks
9 ago on that precise phrase. So I am certainly not quarrelling with Ms.
10 Hanson about that. But clearly, Your Honour, if we do get to points where
11 it does become important to resolve meanings of words and translations, we
12 have to go beyond this particular witness whose expertise lies in other
13 areas.
14 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, I do understand that. But whenever a word
15 appears that comes even close to cleaning, cleansing, mopping, whatever,
16 the Chamber will be immediately alert on the proper meaning of those
17 words. I'm not saying that I'm waking up at night and considering all
18 these different sensations, but it comes close to that.
19 MR. STEWART: We do, Your Honour. But thank you for that
20 observation, Your Honour. We appreciate that.
21 MR. HANNIS:
22 Q. In that regard, I know in this case, cleansing is actually in
23 quotation marks in the original, no?
24 A. Yes, and that is unusual. Again, on the basis of one sentence, I
25 can't speculate as to why it is. But it's unusual to see it in quotation
Page 9908
1 marks.
2 Q. Any other comment on this document?
3 A. No.
4 Q. Next, I think, in your report you talked about how Crisis Staffs
5 exercise some control over the freedom of movement within the
6 municipalities. Tabs 208 and 209, Your Honours, I want to skip over.
7 They're referred to in the footnotes in her report, and go to tab 210,
8 which is master tab 326, and ask you to comment on this one, Ms. Hanson.
9 A. Yes. This is a decision of the Crisis Staff of Ilidza
10 municipality, dated the 19th of May, 1992, signed by Nedeljko Prstojevic
11 as commander of the Crisis Staff, prohibiting the moving out of Croats and
12 Muslims from Butmir, Sokolovic Kolonija, and Hrasnica, and stating that no
13 passage is allowed from the direction of Sarajevo without a special
14 written approval of the Crisis Staff. In this connection, you might
15 remember the intercepted conversation dated the 23rd of May, between
16 Prstojevic and Gagovic, saying that he had set such a policy that no one
17 can come out from Sarajevo.
18 If you'll note that this -- in the distribution of this, it says,
19 number 1, all Crisis Staffs. I would note here what I have noted in my
20 report, that in some municipalities, there was also -- there were also
21 Crisis Staffs at the lower -- the next lower level, the local community
22 level. And we have seen such in Ilidza. I would take this to mean that
23 all of the local level Crisis Staffs, the local community Crisis Staffs,
24 not all Crisis Staffs in Bosnia, because it doesn't seem logical there.
25 That's my interpretation of that particular notation.
Page 9909
1 Q. Thank you.
2 MR. HANNIS: Next, Your Honours --
3 Q. Well, Ms. Hanson, in addition to controlling freedom of movement,
4 in your report, I think you next discuss how the Crisis Staffs established
5 a local judicial system and appointed Serbs to judgeships and
6 prosecutorships and removed non-Serbs.
7 A. Yes. We saw mention of that in Rajko Dukic's speech in the
8 Assembly in July 1992, and we have many documents that indicate that power
9 of the Crisis Staffs.
10 MR. HANNIS: And the next two, Your Honours, tab 211 and 212, I'll
11 will skip over. They're in her report, in the footnotes. But I would
12 like to go to tab 213 in the presentation, which is master tab number 423.
13 Q. This is from Doboj. I'd ask you to comment on this one for us,
14 please.
15 A. Yes. It's perhaps a little clearer in the original, because it's
16 all on one page, but this is a letter from the president of the Serbian
17 municipality of Doboj, also signed by the president of the Autonomous
18 Region of Krajina, dated the 24th of June, 1992, addressed to the Ministry
19 of Justice of the Serbian Republic. I would note that this document was
20 found in the archives of the Ministry of Justice. And the notations on it
21 show -- there's a handwritten notation saying it's implemented, done, yes.
22 It's a recommendation for the appointment of public prosecutors in
23 Doboj, and if I could see that -- yes. It's proposing the leaving --
24 dismissal of three public prosecutors. Their names, I note -- the first
25 two names are Muslim and the third name Ante, son of Stipe, would be
Page 9910
1 typically a Croatian name.
2 Q. And --
3 A. Sorry, the handwritten notations there also say they've been
4 relieved. So it's an indication that the non-Serbs were dismissed and --
5 I'm sorry, that the proposal -- that it was proposed that non-Serbs be
6 dismissed and Serbs appointed.
7 Q. Following on from that, I'd like to show you presentation tab 214.
8 JUDGE HANOTEAU: I'm sorry, a question.
9 MR. HANNIS: Sorry, Your Honour.
10 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] I have a question. Before these
11 events, before this took place, how were prosecutors appointed? Were
12 municipalities -- did municipalities intervene in the appointment of
13 prosecutors? Do we have any information about that? Does that mean that
14 this is a completely new practice that has nothing to do with what was
15 done in the past, with the rules that applied in the past in the republic?
16 Thank you very much, witness.
17 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, may I draw attention to the fact that
18 in the -- I'm looking at tab 213, that the English translation, where it
19 says that -- bottom of page 2, "handwritten and double-underlined
20 relieved," indicates that the word "relieved" is in translation is
21 handwritten and double-underlined. What it doesn't indicate, but it's
22 very clear on the original B/C/S version, is that those three names are
23 crossed out, Midhat Demirovic.
24 THE WITNESS: Pardon me. Yes, I am not familiar with the earlier
25 proceedings, but in general, what I know of the relationship between the
Page 9911
1 authorities of the municipal assembly and those of a higher level, I think
2 it would be much -- a similar practice that the municipal proposes the
3 candidates and the ministry approves or not, generally, approving. But I
4 can't say that with complete confidence. I understand -- I am not
5 claiming here that this is a new power, but rather I am looking at how the
6 Crisis Staff used that power. That's the focus of my --
7 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, the witness appears to be treating my
8 observation as a question. It was purely an observation, and it seems in
9 relation also to one or two other items on this document, that a little
10 bit of care is needed to make sure that the particular items in the
11 translation -- it is seen how they match the items in the original.
12 JUDGE ORIE: Mr. Hannis, would it be possible to have an English
13 translation? Because there's no problem with the translation, as such, as
14 far as I understand, but that all other handwriting, crossing out, is
15 reflected in the English translation and -- well, I understood Ms.
16 Hanson's answer to be that since Judge Hanoteau first put a question,
17 which was not directly related to your observation, rather rightly, that
18 she first answered the question of Judge Hanoteau, and I think we dealt
19 with the other matter by now.
20 MR. STEWART: That may be what happened. I see that now, Your
21 Honour. I just thought that somebody might have made a comment in
22 response to my comment. Anyway, never mind.
23 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Let's proceed.
24 MR. HANNIS: Thank you.
25 Q. Then following on that decision, I wanted to show you presentation
Page 9912
1 tab 214, master tab 423, which appears to relate.
2 A. Yes. It relates -- it is the decision on appointing the public
3 prosecutors in Doboj, signed by Radovan Karadzic as president of the
4 Presidency. And it is the -- the three names, Serbian names, proposed in
5 the previous document. So we had the handwritten annotation that that
6 decision had been -- that proposal had been done, and this is the -- an
7 official decision indicating that it had been acted on.
8 Q. Thank you. Next, I want to go to presentation tab 215, and the
9 master tab number is 424. This is from Banja Luka, and deals with the
10 same issue. Can you tell us what this one shows?
11 A. Yes. This is an interesting document because it shows the process
12 of the proposal of -- and confirmation of appointments of some judicial
13 offices, in this case, in Banja Luka. The first page is the cover letter
14 from the public prosecutors' office in Banja Luka to the War Presidency of
15 the Banja Luka municipal assembly, stating that the War Presidency must
16 give its approval for the appointment of the deputy public prosecutor. So
17 they are forwarding to the War Presidency for its approval a list of
18 candidates for the office of public prosecutors.
19 If we look at the list on the following pages, following three
20 pages in the translation - in the B/C/S, it's two pages, 03234587 through
21 03234588 - if we can see the originals -- in the originals, it's quite
22 striking that it's noted in the translation that all the names are circled
23 except the last name - I'm just looking at the original to confirm it -
24 which is a Muslim name. We can tell who is a Muslim and Serb because that
25 is noted for each name, and it is underlined in handwriting. So there are
Page 9913
1 handwritten annotations circling the numbers and underlining
2 nationalities. The only name that is crossed out is the last Muslim name.
3 Q. Do you have any information for the Court where this particular
4 document was obtained from?
5 A. Yes. This document was found in the archives of the Ministry of
6 Justice, so it indicates that this was forwarded from the public
7 prosecutors' office to the War Presidency, and got from the War Presidency
8 of Banja Luka municipality to the Ministry of Justice.
9 Q. And did you see another document later on actually reflecting what
10 might have been taken in connection with these proposals?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. Let me hand you a document, which is tab number 216, master tab
13 425, and you to comment on that.
14 JUDGE ORIE: Before we do so, may I ask for a clarification on the
15 previous answer. Ms. Hanson, you said only the last name was --
16 THE WITNESS: Well, there are two lists, Your Honour.
17 JUDGE ORIE: Yes.
18 THE WITNESS: The first is the shorter list of candidates for
19 public prosecutors.
20 JUDGE ORIE: Yes.
21 THE WITNESS: And the second list, which we'll get to in a moment,
22 is for judges.
23 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. I went too fast.
24 THE WITNESS: Well, we're jumping ahead to the next document
25 because it relates only to the first list.
Page 9914
1 MR. HANNIS:
2 Q. Which candidates were those, judges or prosecutors?
3 A. Prosecutors. So the first list of prosecutors, the next document
4 that you see, it's the decision on appointing deputy public prosecutors in
5 Banja Luka, signed by Momcilo Krajisnik as president of the Assembly,
6 dated the 11th of August. And that list -- the appointments here
7 correspond to the Serb names on that list of proposed candidates, and the
8 Muslim name is not appointed, which had been X-ed out on the list.
9 Q. Can you refer us to the B/C/S ERN?
10 A. Of the decision? I'm sorry. Of the decision?
11 Q. Yes.
12 A. I'm sorry. It is 03234584 through 03234585.
13 Q. And the last name that was on the list in the previous document
14 among prosecutor candidates was the Muslim name?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. And that person was not appointed?
17 A. Correct.
18 Q. Thank you. Next, I would like to --
19 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] May I ask a question, a very
20 brief question?
21 I'm somewhat confused, I'm somewhat lost, with these lists, and I
22 would like to get an explanation. I'm still with tab 215. We have a
23 first list of names under our eyes here, and this first list of names has
24 11 names. You told us that the last name was a Muslim name, that this
25 name was a Muslim name. That's the eleventh name; is that correct?
Page 9915
1 THE WITNESS: Yes.
2 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] But the following list, what does
3 it represent? We have the second list. We can see that there are 50
4 names on this second list. Some numbers are circled and other numbers are
5 crossed out, or there's a cross over them. You explained this to us, but
6 I didn't really quite understand. Thank you, ma'am.
7 THE WITNESS: Yes. Perhaps, if I can show the original, because
8 it's not in Cyrillic, it might be quite clear. The second list, the
9 longer list, is candidates for judge, so it's separate -- it's not -- it's
10 a separate list from the first list. For the first list, we have the
11 decision on appointments; for this one, we do not. But if you look at the
12 original, for each name, the nationality is underlined, and each name that
13 is underlined is Serb there in the original, Srpkinja or Srbinje is
14 circled. Each name that is not a Serb nationality is crossed out. On the
15 first page of the list, that's 03234589, you can see the first crossed-out
16 name, the nationality Hrvatica, means Croatian. Numbers 8 and 9 -- okay,
17 number 8 is Srpkinja, is a Serb, but I would note that her father is
18 identified as Avdo and the last name is Fazlic -- sorry, her married name
19 is Fazlic. The Avdo would be a typically Muslim name. She identifies
20 herself as Serb, and her name is crossed out. But Fazlic also is more
21 usually a Muslim last name, although that is harder to judge. That is one
22 of the exceptions of a Serb being crossed out. The next name that's
23 crossed out is, in fact, Muslim. The next page, the name that's crossed
24 out, number 14, is Croat. Number 19, crossed out, Yugoslav; 20, Yugoslav,
25 crossed out; 24, Slovene, crossed out; 25, Muslim, crossed out; 26,
Page 9916
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12 Blank page inserted to ensure pagination corresponds between the French and
13 English transcripts.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Page 9917
1 Muslim, crossed out; 29, Yugoslav, crossed, and so on.
2 There are a few Serb names that are crossed out, but there is an
3 explanation following this list that refugees cannot be employed, and the
4 indication is that these are -- the indication from where they worked
5 before, that they are not from Banja Luka, and it is my opinion that it's
6 likely that they were refugees and therefore names were crossed out as not
7 suitable. But it is notable that nobody identified as a Muslim or Croat
8 has their name circled. Somebody marked up this list, it's clear, and
9 identified the nationality by underlining, in addition to naming it when
10 they drew up the list.
11 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Thank you very much, witness.
12 MR. HANNIS: Thank you.
13 Q. Ms. Hanson, I now wanted to move on to another topic. In your
14 report, at paragraph 61, you talk about how Crisis Staffs carried out a
15 policy and procedures for the removal or forcible departure of non-Serbs.
16 I'd like you to take a look at tab 217 in the presentation, that's master
17 tab 141. This is a Crisis Staff decision from the 30th of May, 1992, from
18 Sanski Most. It's a document we've seen before on another topic, but
19 could you tell us how it pertains to this?
20 A. Yes. Under item 2, at the bottom of the first page in
21 translation, the second paragraph on the second page of the B/C/S,
22 00471744, notes that the Crisis Staff needs to find a long-term solution
23 for Muslims and Croats who are not loyal to the constitution and laws of
24 the Serbian Republic of BiH, which means that all those who've not taken
25 up arms and want to change their municipality are to be allowed to move
Page 9918
1 away.
2 The Crisis Staff also notes that they should make contact with the
3 leadership of the Autonomous Region of Krajina regarding implementation on
4 the idea of resettlement of the population.
5 Q. Thank you. Next, I would like to show you presentation tab 218,
6 master tab 426. This is from Bosanski Novi Crisis Staff.
7 A. Yes. This is an announcement of the Crisis Staff of Bosanski
8 Novi, dated the 8th of June, addressed to the citizens of Blagaj and the
9 Japra valley, saying that in regard to the war operations and a decision
10 -- information from the Red Cross of Bosanski Novi about the departure of
11 Muslims -- the problem of the departure of Muslims, the Crisis Staff here
12 advises the citizens that they are prepared to provide peaceful and secure
13 departure of the Muslim population from that area. "With a view to your
14 security, it is necessary to form a departure column immediately. If
15 these proposals are rejected, the Crisis Staff will no longer be able to
16 guarantee security for Muslims in this area."
17 Q. Thank you.
18 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, we would recall you to the testimony of
19 a couple of crime-base witnesses from Bosanski Novi about how they came to
20 be moved out of that area.
21 Q. Next, Ms. Hanson, I would ask you to look at presentation tab 219,
22 master tab 295. This is from, I think, a document that we looked at other
23 portions of before, and I think the excerpt you want to talk about here is
24 on page 10 of the English translation. Can you direct Mr. Krajisnik to
25 the appropriate place in the B/C/S?
Page 9919
1 A. In the B/C/S, it's on page 12 of the document, B0032538, the last
2 full paragraph from the bottom of that page. It notes that 3.500 Muslims
3 from the Japra valley came to an agreement with the Crisis Staff of the
4 municipality of Bosanski Novi, and on the 9th of June, left the
5 municipality in the direction of Doboj. The previous document was dated
6 the 8th of June. "This resettlement was done by rail in a train composed
7 of 22 wagons. The SJB has no precise data because these citizens did not
8 officially unregister their residents in accordance with the law."
9 I take that is a confirmation related to the previous document.
10 Q. Thank you. Let's go on to another municipality. Presentation tab
11 220, master tab 427. This is from the Gacko municipality.
12 A. Yes. It's a proclamation of the War Presidency of Gacko, dated
13 the 31st of July, 1992, a proclamation to the Muslim people in Bileca,
14 telling them to come down out of -- where they had sought refuge in the
15 mountains, saying -- I take attention to item 3 on the list, bottom of the
16 first page of the translation; in the B/C/S, on the second page, 02096314,
17 item 3 on the first -- on the top of the page.
18 "After leaving the mountains, you will immediately be put on
19 buses. The women, children and the elderly will be taken where they wish
20 to go, while the men fit for military service will be taken to the
21 garrison prison in Bileca."
22 And item 5 on the next page in the translation: "The possible
23 destinations are Stolac, Mostar, and Macedonia. There are no other
24 possibilities due to the present circumstances."
25 So although they say that they may go -- be sent where they wish
Page 9920
1 to go, in fact their only choices are in either territory held by the
2 Bosnian and Croat forces -- Muslim and Croat forces in Bosnia or
3 Macedonia, another country altogether. And the men, of course, will be
4 sent to the prison.
5 Q. Thank you. I now want to show you tab 221, master tab number 13.
6 This is from the Prnjavor municipality.
7 A. Yes. This is a decision of the Crisis Staff, dated the 22nd of
8 June, 1992, "a decision on the organised moving out of refugees disloyal
9 to the authorities of the Serbian Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina."
10 Under Article 1, it says: "All refugees who are disloyal to the
11 authorities, as well as refugees whose relatives are members of enemy
12 formations, are obliged to leave Prnjavor in an organised fashion." And
13 it tasks the police station, the public security station, to implement
14 this decision.
15 Q. Thank you. Now let me show you tab 222, master tab number 221.
16 This is from the Bosanska Krupa municipality, although in connection with
17 that I see there's a different name on the front of that report.
18 A. Yes. Krupa na Uni, Krupa on the Una river, just as we saw that
19 Bosanski Petrovac dropped the "Bosanski", similarly here, Krupa is
20 dropping the Bosnian identification and calling itself simply the Krupa on
21 the Una.
22 Q. This is a long document.
23 A. It's on page 5 in the translation, the last two paragraphs on that
24 page, and I will look for the -- there it is. The B/C/S is page 4 of the
25 B/C/S, that is, 00552818. It mentions that -- in discussing the work of
Page 9921
1 the Crisis Staff, they discuss the Crisis Staff's involvement in the
2 removal of Muslims. In the beginning of the third paragraph on page --
3 I'm sorry, in the middle of the third paragraph:
4 "The War Presidency of the Serbian municipality offered the
5 Muslims two options. They could organise themselves and, with our
6 guarantees and full protection, move out to the destination of their
7 transfer, or this would be done by military means."
8 In the next -- beginning of the next paragraph, they explain that:
9 "The reason for adopting this decision on the temporary transfer was the
10 physical safety of the Muslim people and the historically proved and
11 confirmed nobility and kindness of Serbs who do not have a propensity for
12 crimes and genocide."
13 Q. Let me ask you for a comment regarding --
14 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, in relation to that, of course it's
15 necessary to avoid reading out all sorts of superfluous context, but from
16 the English translation, what Ms. Hanson read out here in open court
17 started in the middle of a sentence, and really, in this particular case,
18 I do suggest that the whole sentence should have been read out and should
19 now be read out.
20 JUDGE ORIE: Please indicate where you'd like Ms. Hanson to start.
21 MR. STEWART: The words "the weak response" in the translation,
22 which is almost halfway down that penultimate paragraph on page 5.
23 MR. HANNIS:
24 Q. Did you find that, Ms. Hanson?
25 A. You wish me to read that?
Page 9922
1 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, please.
2 A. "The weak response or total disregard of Muslims to the call for
3 surrender of arms, and Alija's threat that Krupa must become green
4 whatever the cost, forced the War Presidency of the Serbian municipality
5 to offer the Muslims two options: They could organise themselves and,
6 with our guarantees and full protection, move out to the destination of
7 their transfer; or this would be done by military means."
8 MR. STEWART: Thank you, Your Honour.
9 MR. HANNIS:
10 Q. Before we leave that one, the second statement you read to us made
11 a reference to the temporary nature of the removal. Can you comment on
12 that what regard to what Miroslav Vjestica from Krupa had to say in the
13 municipality?
14 A. He said to the Bosnian Serb Assembly on the 12th of May that he --
15 having heard the happy news of where the borders will be set, he does not
16 think that there will be a place for Muslims to return to.
17 Q. Thank you. Next, I would like to show you presentation tab 223,
18 master tab number 342. This is also from Bosanska Krupa.
19 A. Yes. This is an order of the War Presidency of Bosanska Krupa,
20 dated the 22nd of May, 1992, an order to evacuate the remaining Muslim
21 population from the territory of Bosanska Krupa, and, again, tasking the
22 public security station and the military police to implement this order on
23 evacuation. And the evacuation should be directed towards Cazin Krajina.
24 Cazin Krajina was an area of Bosnia held by -- not claimed by the Serbs,
25 so Bosnian Muslim territory.
Page 9923
1 I would note here, it says "the remaining population," those
2 who've not yet left are to leave.
3 Q. Thank you.
4 MR. HANNIS: Next, Your Honours, at presentation tab 224, master
5 tab 429.
6 Q. This is an intercept, an intercepted telephone conversation from
7 the 12th of May, 1992. And can you tell us who the speakers are and where
8 we're beginning on both the English and B/C/S versions of the hard copy?
9 A. The speaker -- one speaker is identified as Nedeljko Prstojevic,
10 as we've seen, commander of the Ilidza Crisis Staff. The others are an
11 unidentified Milenko and then an unidentified Novakovic. I don't have any
12 information on who they might be. The excerpt starts in the seventh box
13 -- oh, no, I'm sorry, I don't -- the sixth -- fifth box from the bottom,
14 Prstojevic saying, "Why did Mika phone me?" I'll find it in the B/C/S.
15 It's at the top -- towards the top of the second page, 04013854, the sixth
16 box from the top.
17 Q. Thank you.
18 MR. HANNIS: I would note for the interpreters, as I recall, I
19 think this is a pretty rapid conversation, and it's about two pages.
20 We're ready to play it.
21 [Intercept played]
22 THE INTERPRETER: [Voiceover]
23 "Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Why did Mika phone me?
24 Milenko: Milenko ... phoned you to check with you ... these
25 people in Kotorac.
Page 9924
1 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Yes.
2 Milenko: What should we do with them?
3 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Did you arrest them? What did you do.
4 Milenko: People are down there on ... Just a second, one second
5 ... (Milenko is telling people in the room to be quiet) Yes?
6 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Hello?
7 Milenko: Yes?
8 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: And where are those people? Have they been
9 arrested?
10 Milenko: No.
11 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: What then?
12 Milenko: ... Down there on the road, all of them. Men are
13 separated from women.
14 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Ha ...
15 Milenko: Just a second, just a second.
16 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: ... Up there... right?
17 Milenko: He says men ... I've just received the word: Men are in
18 the Kula prison, and women went in the direction of Butmir.
19 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Put Tepavcevic on.
20 Milenko: Here, here's Novakovic. He will talk with you. It's
21 Prstojevic, stop fooling around.
22 NOVAKOVIC: Hello?
23 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Hello?
24 NOVAKOVIC: Hi, Nedja.
25 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Hi.
Page 9925
1 NOVAKOVIC: How are you?
2 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: I'm fine. Have you been cleaning Kotorac
3 today?
4 NOVAKOVIC: They have. I don't know the exact details, because I
5 was engaged otherwise.
6 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Yes.
7 NOVAKOVIC: Well, if you want we will call you later, well, while
8 ...
9 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: That's ok, but tell me, please, I beg of
10 you, why did you take women to Butmir?
11 NOVAKOVIC: They said women were not in Butmir but ...
12 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: But?
13 NOVAKOVIC: Well, in Butmir, yes. Not to KP Dom, but to Butmir.
14 That's where they're going.
15 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: They cannot go to Butmir, we'll mop up
16 Butmir in time as well.
17 NOVAKOVIC: Aha.
18 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Butmir will be mopped up, Sokolovic will be
19 mopped up, Hrasnica will be mopped up.
20 NOVAKOVIC: Well, I don't know where to take them?
21 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: They will all ... There is Bascarsija.
22 Please take all of them to Bascarsija, on foot.
23 NOVAKOVIC: Aha, aha.
24 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Women.
25 NOVAKOVIC: OK, now I'll ...
Page 9926
1 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: And men to prison.
2 NOVAKOVIC: OK. I'll check with them now and then I'll let you
3 know.
4 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Yes. Tell them, those who convert to
5 Orthodox religion on the spot, they can stay, women and children.
6 NOVAKOVIC: Aha. OK. OK, now I'll ...
7 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: Do it, please, but don't make mistakes ...
8 You've done an excellent job, but it means that Butmir will be mopped up
9 in time. Tell that to the people there.
10 NOVAKOVIC: Yes, yes. OK.
11 Nedeljko PRSTOJEVIC: There you go. Cheers.
12 NOVAKOVIC: OK."
13 MR. HANNIS:
14 Q. Ms. Hanson, do you have any comment on that?
15 A. Well, first of all, the word that is translated as mopped up here
16 is cistiti, or cistite. And in terms of what he means, mopping up, his
17 emphasis that women who convert to Orthodox religion can stay, men will go
18 to prison; otherwise, the women go to Bascarsija, that is, the centre of
19 Sarajevo, which was held by the Bosnian Muslims at this time, indicates
20 that it's not just about military operations to my mind; that those who
21 convert to the Orthodox religion can stay, is a striking statement. And
22 that he's planning to -- he has intention to cleanse, clear, mop up,
23 certain neighbourhoods and therefore does not want more Muslims sent
24 there, I think, is indicative of an -- his planning for future operations
25 in those regions, those areas, neighbourhoods.
Page 9927
1 Q. And did you see some -- we've talked about a few examples of where
2 the Muslims were being removed from individual municipalities. Did you
3 see some examples where there was coordination between more than one
4 municipality in this process?
5 A. Yes, I did.
6 Q. Let me show you tab 225 in the presentation, master tab 343, and
7 ask you what that is.
8 A. This document is called "Conclusions Adopted at a Subregional
9 Meeting of Political Representatives of the Municipalities of Bihac,
10 Bosanski Petrovac, Srpska Krupa" is how Krupa is described here, "Sanski
11 Most, Prijedor, Bosanski Novi, and Kljuc," and sent to a Crisis Staff of
12 the autonomous region of Banja Luka, the leadership of the Serbian
13 Republic of Bosnia-Herzegovina in Sarajevo, and the 1st Krajina Corps.
14 It's dated the 7th of June, 1992.
15 I would note in this context, particularly item 6, which is on the
16 second page of the translation and also of the B/C/S.
17 "That all seven municipalities here agree that Muslims and Croats
18 should move out of our municipalities until a level is reached where
19 Serbian authority can be maintained and implemented on its own territory
20 in each of these municipalities."
21 The paragraph goes on to note that if the ARK leadership fails to
22 solve this issue, "our seven municipalities will take all Muslims and
23 Croats under military escort from our municipalities to the centre of
24 Banja Luka."
25 Q. Thank you. Next, I want to go on to another paragraph in your
Page 9928
1 report, paragraph 62. You talk about how Crisis Staffs oversaw the
2 removal of non-Serbs by establishing variously named committees or
3 agencies, for example, Committee for Immigration, Travel Agency, Exchange
4 Agency.
5 Let me show you tab 226 in the presentation, master tab 325. This
6 is from Kotor Varos. Tell us about this one, please.
7 A. This is minutes of the War Presidency of Kotor Varos, dated the
8 14th of July, 1992. On the first page in both the English and B/C/S,
9 under item 2, the War Presidency says that: "Activities relating to
10 moving out the population failed to meet expectations. This task must be
11 dealt with in a much more organised fashion. An agency has to be
12 established to handle these matters."
13 I've seen agencies, as you mentioned, various kinds of agencies,
14 some dealing with the exchange of property of those leaving and others
15 with larger issues of how to move out -- move the population.
16 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, we'll skip the next tab, 227. It's
17 referred to in a footnote in her report, and go to presentation tab 228,
18 master tab 350.
19 Q. This is a document from Sanski Most on the 2nd of July, 1992. Did
20 the Crisis Staffs set any criteria before people would be allowed to
21 depart?
22 A. Yes. I saw several decisions on the criteria for moving out.
23 This is one such decision from Sanski Most, dated the 2nd of July, 1992.
24 Under Article 1, it notes that families and people may leave voluntarily
25 from Sanski Most if they give a statement to the appropriate municipal
Page 9929
1 organ that they are permanently leaving, and that they are leaving their
2 real property to Sanski Most municipality.
3 Q. Now, you mentioned -- did you see similar requirements in some of
4 the other municipalities for being allowed to depart, in particular an
5 indication that the departure was permanent?
6 A. Several such decisions specify the arrangements for the real
7 estate and the permanency of that -- the disposing of the real estate.
8 Q. Let me take you next to tab 229 in the presentation, master tab
9 344. This is from Petrovac.
10 A. Yes. It's an information or statement based on the decision of
11 the War Presidency, dated 31st of July, 1992, and the statement is
12 regarding the conditions by which Muslims may move away voluntarily from
13 the municipality. And they may do so if they either exchange -- sign a
14 contract on the exchange of their property or leave their property to the
15 state. Notable here, at the bottom -- the last sentence of the first
16 item, that "property may be given to close relatives from mixed
17 marriages." So Muslims may leave but they -- the implication here is that
18 only those from mixed marriages can leave their property to
19 relatives. Others have to either exchange it or give it to the state.
20 Q. Thank you. Let me show you next presentation tab 230, master tab
21 354 --
22 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] May I just ask a question? Did
23 you find some examples, Witness, where there was an exchange of real
24 estate? You seem to suggest to us that people would accept to sell and to
25 receive another building in exchange, or another apartment in exchange.
Page 9930
1 Do you have examples showing that this in fact took place?
2 THE WITNESS: I do not recall seeing such examples; however, I
3 would -- in that respect, I'm always dependent upon the evidence we have,
4 and such agreements might be kept by people -- the people involved. And
5 because we have records of -- from the municipal side, such agreements may
6 not have entered the municipal record. But in terms of the documents I
7 examined for this, I do not recall seeing such agreements, but I do see
8 many indications of agencies being set up for this exchange, of the
9 municipal authorities apparently creating the possibility for that.
10 MR. HANNIS: And Your Honour --
11 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Thank you, madam.
12 MR. HANNIS: -- if I may indicate, I believe in the trial so far, I
13 think both from one or two viva voce witnesses and some of the 92 bis
14 materials, we have had some of our crime-base witnesses speak to this
15 particular issue. I can't point you to a specific point, Your Honour, but
16 there is some evidence on that that may be of assistance to you.
17 JUDGE ORIE: If my recollection is right, it was one of the Pale
18 witnesses.
19 MR. HANNIS: I think he did talk about an exchange of property and
20 what he got when he got to Sarajevo. Thank you, Your Honour.
21 Q. Next, I think you have before you the presentation tab 230 --
22 A. Yes, minutes of the War Presidency of Kotor Varos, dated the 29th
23 of July, 1992. Here, I would draw your attention to item number 7, that
24 the War Presidency says that people "moving away should be informed that
25 they are allowed to take with them no more than 300 Deutschemarks."
Page 9931
1 Q. Thank you. Next, with regard to this process, I want to ask you
2 about tab number 231 in the presentation, master tab 355. This is from
3 Bosanska Krupa.
4 A. Yes. This is instructions on the evacuation of refugees -- of the
5 inhabitants and refugees from the local community of Arapusa. It's signed
6 by a representative from Arapusa from the refugee committee and from the
7 command of the battalion, dated the 1st of May, 1992.
8 At the beginning of the instructions, they refer to the order of
9 the war staff of the Serb municipality of Bosanska Krupa, dated the 29th
10 of April, 1992, by which the evacuation of the inhabitants and refugees
11 from Bosanska Krupa is ordered. And it's showing that on the basis of
12 that order, the local community has organised -- prepared a plan of
13 evacuation. Arapusa, I would point out, was a predominantly Muslim
14 settlement.
15 Q. Thank you.
16 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, the next one, I think, we'll skip, 232.
17 This is in Ms. Hanson's report in a footnote and pertains to payment of
18 transportation for refugees from Zvornik.
19 Q. 233 in the presentation, master tab 300. Ms. Hanson, this is from
20 Sanski Most municipality.
21 A. Yes. The conclusions of the Crisis Staff of Sanski Most, dated
22 the 23rd of June, 1992. Here, I would draw your attention to what is
23 listed as item (h) on the first page; in the B/C/S, I'm just checking
24 where it -- oh, yes, it's (g) in the B/C/S. No, I'm sorry, I'm confused
25 here. I'm sorry, it's at the bottom of the first page in the B/C/S, under
Page 9932
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12 Blank page inserted to ensure pagination corresponds between the French and
13 English transcripts.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Page 9933
1 letter (e). The Cyrillic -- it's not -- anyway, I'm sorry, I'm confused.
2 The sentence I want to read is that: "Nedeljko Rasula and Mladen
3 Lukic are given the task of travelling to Prijedor to negotiate quantities
4 of fuel for the use of Sanski Most municipality and at the same time to
5 ask about the possibilities of the passage of a convoy of people who would
6 like to travel by rail into Central Bosnia."
7 Central Bosnia, at this time, I take that to be a reference to
8 territory held by the Bosnian Muslim forces. And so we see that the
9 Crisis Staff is talking to other municipalities about arranging passage --
10 arranging convoys.
11 Q. Thank you.
12 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, that takes us to the end of binder
13 number 5. We're just -- I don't know if you want to take a break at the
14 normal 10.30 time; in light of our late start, if you want to continue on.
15 JUDGE ORIE: We have to take two breaks anyhow, so whether this
16 would be a better moment or after the -- you've introduced your new
17 subject. I'll leave it up to you. But somewhere within the next seven to
18 eight minutes.
19 MR. HANNIS: Let me just ask her a question to follow up on the
20 topics we've just been talking about, and then I'll ask if we can take a
21 break.
22 Q. Ms. Hanson, that just concludes our discussion of how the Crisis
23 Staffs were involved in the removal of non-Serbs. In some of the
24 documents we saw, and some that you referred to in your report, the
25 municipality authorities and in some of the higher level authorities, they
Page 9934
1 seemed to indicate that they're simply trying to help the non-Serbs who
2 want to leave the area. Do you have any comment on that?
3 A. We do see that. However, I have not seen references to Crisis
4 Staffs discussing the possibility of moving those people to another safe
5 part of the Serbian municipality or to another safe area of the Bosnian
6 Serb territory. But the idea of safety seems to refer to moving them out
7 of Serb territory altogether.
8 Q. And did you see in some of the documents you reviewed for this
9 where there were discussions, for example, in the municipality, in the
10 Crisis Staff meetings, where local Muslims or other non-Serbs were
11 requesting to be allowed to stay?
12 A. I'm sorry, could you repeat the question?
13 Q. Did you see any examples in the documents where the local Muslims
14 were requesting to be allowed to stay, even though there were wartime
15 conditions and a lot of anti-non-Serb bias?
16 A. No, I don't recall seeing any such requests of Muslims who wanted
17 to say.
18 Q. As for the removal, whether it was temporary or permanent, did you
19 see any evidence to suggest that it was not temporary?
20 A. Yes, we saw -- as we see, the decisions regarding property
21 indicate that it's permanent. We do see -- we looked at briefly in the
22 Krupa War Presidency, they say it was for their temporary removal, but we
23 also have the comments of a member of that War Presidency that he does not
24 expect the Muslims to return. We also see War Presidencies and Crisis
25 Staffs deciding who can return and cannot, and taking -- making efforts to
Page 9935
1 return Serbs but not making the same efforts to return non-Serbs.
2 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, I'm about to go into another area. Can
3 we take a break at this point?
4 JUDGE ORIE: Then we'll have a break. We had a late start --
5 we'll resume at 10.55, five minutes to 11.00.
6 --- Recess taken at 10.30 a.m.
7 --- On resuming at 11.05 a.m.
8 JUDGE ORIE: The fact that the Chamber returned late gives no
9 right to the parties. It's always because there are a lot of things to do
10 during the breaks which sometimes take even more time than expected.
11 Please proceed, Mr. Hannis.
12 MR. HANNIS: Thank you, Your Honour.
13 Q. Now, Ms. Hanson, we just finished talking about the removal of
14 non-Serbs from the municipality, and discussed the issue about whether
15 that was meant to be temporary or permanent. In your report, at paragraph
16 63, you talked about how the Crisis Staff oversaw the collection and
17 redistribution of the property that had been left behind when the
18 non-Serbs left or were forced to leave, and, in many cases, signed over
19 their property.
20 Binder tab 234 is a document we looked at before, which is from a
21 Presidency decision, and I'll skip over that one, Your Honours, and go to
22 235, which is master tab 357, and, Ms. Hanson, ask you to direct us to the
23 page in that document you want to talk about and what point it illustrates
24 regarding ...
25 A. Yes. This is also a document we have seen before, the accounts of
Page 9936
1 the Serbian municipality of Ilijas. But in this context, I would just
2 turn you to the last page of the translation, the B/C/S page 02252626,
3 where, after the summary, there are some remarks. And the first remark
4 notes that some of the income came from goods taken by the Crisis Staff's
5 order, from the shop of Mirsad Tokac -- I'm sorry, it does not say that it
6 was part of the income. I was misunderstanding from the first page. But
7 it says that goods were taken by order of the Crisis Staff from the man's
8 shop to the Trgopromet company. So it's -- the name of the shop owner,
9 Mirsad, is a typically Muslim name.
10 Q. And was there an estimated value of the property that was taken?
11 A. Yes. 1.500.000 dinars, which is about -- I had the figure in my
12 notes, I'm sorry, I don't have it with me.
13 Q. I think you had indicated it was somewhere in the neighbourhood of
14 $4.600 at the time.
15 A. Yes, just as an indication.
16 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, I'd like to skip the next presentation
17 236, it's a document in the footnotes to her report, and go to tab 237,
18 which is master tab number 430.
19 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Mr. Hannis, I have a question for
20 the witness, if you don't mind.
21 MR. HANNIS: Certainly, Your Honour.
22 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] In document 235, I do not
23 understand "for incomes." What was the status of the Snaga shop or
24 supermarket manager, Ozren Hotel? Maybe this is rather naive question,
25 but had these shops being requisitioned? Did they belong to someone?
Page 9937
1 Were these shops then operated directly by the municipality of the
2 commune? Can you give us some information about this. It's not the
3 Crisis Staff who was directly operating or managing these establishments.
4 Did they appoint someone to operate these establishments? Can you provide
5 us some more information about this, please?
6 THE WITNESS: I have no further information on these institutions
7 in Ilijas. Ilijas is not a municipality for which we have very detailed
8 reports, so I don't know whether this came as a tax on -- a sales tax, tax
9 on income from these businesses, or whether these were businesses whose
10 profits went directly to the municipality. I have no further information.
11 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Thank you. But, in other cases
12 you've studied, was it customary for municipalities to directly manage, to
13 directly operate goods or properties that, in the past, belonged to
14 individuals? Do you have any other examples?
15 THE WITNESS: I have no examples of that, to my knowledge, to my
16 recollection.
17 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Thank you, Witness.
18 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, I would note that in our upcoming
19 witness schedule, I think we have two or three witnesses from Ilijas who
20 will testify in a couple of weeks, so we may be able to address that issue
21 at that time. Thank you.
22 Q. Ms. Hanson --
23 MR. STEWART: Subject to the ruling on the application for an
24 adjournment, Mr. Hannis means, Your Honour.
25 MR. HANNIS: Certainly.
Page 9938
1 JUDGE ORIE: That's only for the weeks to come. But I take it
2 that's somewhere in the presentation of the Prosecution case, and that's
3 how I understood Mr. Hannis's remark. The timing is, I fully agree,
4 totally in the hands of the Chamber.
5 Please proceed.
6 MR. HANNIS: Thank you.
7 Q. Ms. Hanson, I'd like to go next to presentation tab 237, which is
8 master tab 430. This is a document from Prnjavor.
9 A. Yes. The decision of the Crisis Staff, dated the 23rd of June,
10 1992, on -- instructing those who have -- citizens of the municipality who
11 have left to report to the municipal secretariat for economy, urban
12 planning and finance, by the 10th of July. If they fail to report, their
13 property "shall be declared the property of the state and placed at the
14 disposal of the municipality of Prnjavor." I would note in this context
15 that it's not a long time period from the date of the decision to the date
16 by which they lose their right to the property.
17 Q. And is there any indication in that document that the proceeds
18 from that property would be held in trust in the event that the owners
19 were to return after the conflict died down?
20 A. No. It says it would be declared the property of the state and at
21 the disposal of the municipality.
22 Q. Let me show you next presentation tab 238, master tab 364. This
23 is a document from Kotor Varos, on the 28th of July, 1992.
24 A. From the minutes of the War Presidency. Under item 2 on the
25 middle of the first page of the translation: "In relation to the report
Page 9939
1 of the chief of the public security station on confiscating the money of
2 individuals who are moving out, it was established that this was being
3 done without anyone's order, i.e., in an unauthorised manner," and so it
4 was decided that the money confiscated in this manner -- I'll finish the
5 sentence. I was trying to summarise, not trying to leave out anything
6 significant. "... this can have a negative effect on the operation and
7 the reputation of all of us. It was decided that the money confiscated in
8 this matter will be used to help the families of soldiers killed and other
9 essential costs of the Municipality."
10 Q. Thank you. In your report, at paragraph 64, you indicate that
11 that is a sign that the removal was meant to be permanent rather than
12 temporary, that some Crisis Staffs took measures to ensure non-Serbs would
13 not return.
14 Let me show you presentation tab 239, master tab 367, in that
15 regard.
16 A. This is a document on a conclusion of the war staff of Kalinovik,
17 discussing a decision made on the 17th of May. It doesn't quite have the
18 form of a regular conclusion, but it is signed and stamped. It's just
19 that the date isn't in the usual place.
20 Notable here, the second paragraph. The conclusion is regarding
21 men of military age, of Muslim nationality, that they were to report to
22 the secretariat for national defence between the 20th and the 25th of May;
23 if they fail to report at this time, they shall be proclaimed opponents of
24 the SOS, banned from returning to the municipality, and their property
25 shall be confiscated.
Page 9940
1 Q. I think you have two more documents related to this point.
2 Presentation tab 240, master tab 368, this is from Kotor Varos Crisis
3 Staff or War Presidency, on the 11th of November, 1992.
4 A. At the end of item 2, the last paragraph of item 2, the War
5 Presidency wants to form a commission to make a selection of which -- to
6 allow some refugees to return to their homes, but not others.
7 Q. Does it mention any criteria which will be used for that purpose?
8 A. It doesn't specify that here, but it's the War Presidency,
9 apparently, who's setting up the commission.
10 Q. Finally, on this issue, let me show you presentation tab 241,
11 master tab 366. This is from the Ilidza municipality.
12 A. It's titled "A Programme for the Return of Serbs from SR
13 Yugoslavia," dated the 21st of June, 1992. Under item 4, at the bottom of
14 page 1, this plan notes that -- if I could just see the ...
15 It seems that the revised translation has not gotten into the
16 binders. Could I read the B/C/S and have the interpreters translate the
17 relevant passage?
18 Q. Please do.
19 A. Okay. I'm getting confused with these. Okay.
20 [Interpretation] "From the Serbian municipality of Ilidza, not
21 only the Muslim and Croatian population moved out or ran away, but also
22 our own Serbian population. In order to have the Serbian population
23 return, we kindly ask the government of the Serbian Bosnia-Herzegovina to
24 adopt the following stances: 1, to take every possible step for the
25 return of the displaced persons, refugeed Serbs."
Page 9941
1 [In English] The emphasis in the original is that not only Muslims
2 and Croats left Ilidza, but also "our Serbs," and the emphasis is on
3 returning the Serbs from Yugoslavia. So the intention here of this
4 municipality appears to be to make -- take efforts to return the Serbs,
5 but not all who left.
6 Q. And no mention of non-Serbs?
7 A. No mention of returning non-Serbs.
8 Q. Now, Ms. Hanson, that concludes the documents we wanted to show in
9 the presentation related to your report. We talked in the beginning that
10 you had prepared some case studies for three separate municipalities to
11 sort of reflect the overall points you've been making.
12 Before we move to that, was there anything you wanted to say to,
13 sort of, sum up what we've talked about so far, before we do that, or do
14 you want to go to the case study of Kljuc?
15 A. I would direct the Court to my report. My written conclusions are
16 perhaps more eloquent than I can say now.
17 Q. Thank you.
18 MR. HANNIS: And, Your Honours, those are contained in paragraphs
19 65 through 69 of her report.
20 Q. With that, then, Your Honours, I would like to talk about some of
21 the case studies.
22 First of all, would you tell us, briefly, how you chose those
23 municipalities, and why you chose them, and what you intend to show with
24 these case studies?
25 A. I wanted to show what a good collection of Crisis Staff documents
Page 9942
1 can tell us about the day-to-day operations of Crisis Staffs, and how they
2 illustrate the themes which I've discussed. So I selected municipalities
3 for which we have good, consistent documentary evidence, none of it, of
4 course, perfect, 100 per cent complete. And many municipalities do not
5 have such extensive collections. But that was one criterion.
6 I also -- to show the extent of the pattern, I wanted a
7 geographical distribution, so, according to those criteria, the best
8 examples were Kljuc, Trnovo, and Bratunac.
9 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, could I just observe that -- I've just
10 noticed that when there was a reference a few moments ago to paragraph 65
11 through 69 of Ms. Hanson's report, the numbering doesn't seem to fit. Of
12 course, this is evidence in chief and I get to cross-examine, but I don't
13 think the actual paragraph numbering fits what it was probably intended to
14 say as a wrap-up of that bit of the evidence.
15 JUDGE ORIE: I also notice that somewhere in this range we jump to
16 the conclusions, for example, if I'm --
17 MR. STEWART: But 69 doesn't fit either, because 69 is the second
18 paragraph of the section dealing with conclusions, so I don't think it can
19 have been intended to be 65 to 69.
20 JUDGE ORIE: Ms. Hanson.
21 THE WITNESS: I don't have my report with me.
22 MR. HANNIS: I'm sorry, Your Honour, I misspoke. I was looking at
23 an earlier version. I think I should have said paragraphs 68 through 72.
24 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, that's the conclusions, then. So Mr. Hannis was
25 referring to your conclusions.
Page 9943
1 MR. HANNIS: Thank you. I thank Mr. Stewart.
2 JUDGE ORIE: May I, before you do so, Ms. Hanson, I do understand
3 that there are municipalities where there is more documentation as to
4 others. You used the words "pattern," which is, of course -- well, I
5 would say, to establish a pattern is not always an easy matter. May I
6 take it that, if -- from any of the less-documented municipalities, if
7 there is documentation which would go against your conclusion of what
8 would be your conclusion on the well-documented municipalities, you will
9 draw our attention to that when dealing with the matter.
10 THE WITNESS: Yes, of course, Your Honour.
11 JUDGE ORIE: Because we're talking about three municipalities.
12 There were many municipalities, and, of course, if you say they are
13 well-documented and this would allow us to establish, I would say, what
14 would be a pattern in these three municipalities, and might be a pattern
15 for the other municipalities as well on the condition that there are not
16 contradictory elements in those documents pertaining to the other
17 municipalities. Of course, I'm not asking for every detail. But if in
18 one of the other municipalities, although less documented, if you find
19 one, two, or three clear indications that it was different there, we would
20 like to be informed about that.
21 THE WITNESS: To clarify my comments, when presenting these case
22 studies, I'm not claiming that everything that happened in these
23 municipalities happened elsewhere. I'm not taking them to stand for other
24 municipalities. When I referred to a pattern, I meant the themes that I
25 discuss in my report. When I discuss a theme, such as the military role
Page 9944
1 or the question of detention centres, on one topic, I take from many
2 municipalities, and so we've been jumping around with a lot of documents.
3 What I wanted to do with the case studies was turn that study upside down
4 and say, Here's one municipality; what, of the topics I've discussed, can
5 we see there?
6 So I'm saying here's what happened in Kljuc. I'm not trying to
7 say that what happened in Kljuc happened in the same way in other
8 municipalities, but rather, the themes that I've discussed, we can see all
9 in one -- or a fairly finite set of documents.
10 JUDGE ORIE: That's clear. And you pointed in your report already
11 to sometimes a pattern not being very clear, such as on the military
12 matters, where you clearly indicated that it was different, depending on
13 presence of the JNA, different on whether orders were given or received.
14 So that's just for our understanding, that we know what you're talking
15 about if you talk about a pattern.
16 THE WITNESS: Yes.
17 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, thank you.
18 MR. HANNIS: Thank you, Your Honour.
19 Q. To follow up on that, Ms. Hanson, I think you've made that point
20 in your report, but we've also talked about this before, that you see wide
21 variation with regard to many of the themes in the various municipalities;
22 correct?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. And you've talked about some of the factors that influence that.
25 Could you go through two or three of those for us again? I know one we
Page 9945
1 talked about: Location.
2 A. Location.
3 Q. And how did that affect?
4 A. Well, how closely the municipality was located to areas of
5 conflict, or how heavy the conflict was in that area; how close to the
6 border of the Serbian territory as opposed to being in the centre; the --
7 Q. You talked about timing.
8 A. The timing, as we saw, is -- what obtained in April is not
9 necessarily the same situation as obtained in June. My report, as I note,
10 is concentrated on that time period mostly, in terms of the most
11 interesting events at that time.
12 Q. And I think you mentioned before personalities.
13 A. The personalities involved. Some personalities just had more
14 interest in moving and shaking on the ground; some personalities had
15 closer contacts to the centre because of personal ties and political --
16 long-standing political ties. So that can also be a factor.
17 Also, the makeup of the population. We talk about variant A or
18 variant B, but, of course, some were much more heavily Serb, with very few
19 non-Serbs. Some had a closer balance of population. So those were all
20 factors.
21 I have to point out also, from my end, one variation is the amount
22 of evidence available to me, and I cannot know what we don't have. I
23 cannot know how much another municipality might have had documents that
24 were not made -- never got to the Tribunal, so that can also influence my
25 appearance of the pattern.
Page 9946
1 JUDGE ORIE: No one asks you to take into consideration material
2 you do not have. Only the fact that you have little information on
3 certain municipalities should make you more cautious in drawing any
4 conclusions.
5 Well, I think the context of your case studies is thus established
6 in such a way that we'd like to listen to it.
7 MR. HANNIS: Thank you, Your Honour.
8 Q. Now, with regard to Kljuc, before I show you the first document,
9 can you tell us briefly, what was the universe of documents from which you
10 were able to draw on in respect of that municipality?
11 A. We have a lot of minutes, handwritten I might note, of the SDS of
12 Kljuc, as well as a book of minutes of the Crisis Staff of Kljuc. That
13 book of minutes starts on the 27th of May, but prior to that we have other
14 -- and subsequent to that, because I believe it ends at the end of June,
15 we have other decisions of the Crisis Staff and War Presidency, and we
16 have a handwritten diary of a member of the Crisis Staff and War
17 Presidency. Kljuc is a municipality with quite good documentation
18 overall, which is, as I said, one of the criterion for selection.
19 Q. Let me begin by handing you presentation tab 242, which is master
20 tab 41, from the 23rd of December, 1991.
21 A. This is the minutes of the meeting of the executive board of the
22 SDS on the 23rd of December, 1991. We have seen this document briefly in
23 the discussion of the implementation of the 19 December instructions. But
24 just to take it a little more to see what the municipality was doing in
25 reaction and how -- to these instructions, and how they discussed them.
Page 9947
1 Kljuc was -- had a very close balance of Serbs and Muslims. The
2 Serbs were a slight majority, just over 49 per cent, while the Muslims
3 were, I believe, just over 47. So it was A, in terms of Serb majority,
4 but a close balance.
5 As we've seen before, under agenda item 1, briefing on the
6 materials arrived from the Serbian Assembly. Veljko Kondic informed the
7 meeting of the instructions for the organisation and activities of the
8 Serbian people in BiH. "All organs will be required to act in accordance
9 with the instructions. Whoever is not ready to fulfil its duties should
10 say so immediately, and it will not be held against him."
11 JUDGE ORIE: Ms. Hanson, we all are speaking more quickly when we
12 read than when we have to invent the words at the very moment.
13 THE WITNESS: Yes, my apologies.
14 A. I would note, then, further down on that page, which is in the
15 B/C/S -- because these are handwritten Cyrillic, finding the B/C/S will
16 always take me a moment longer. It's on page 00914529, in the middle of
17 the page. The composition of the Crisis Staff is consistent with the 19
18 December instructions. It includes the deputy in the Assembly. The
19 deputy from Kljuc was Rajko Kalabic, and we'll see that he speaks at this
20 meeting. I would also note that Ljuban Bajic is named as secretary of the
21 Crisis Staff. I note that because his diary is one of our exhibits. All
22 the appointments that they named to the Crisis Staff are consistent with
23 the 19 December instructions. And at the top of page 2 in the
24 translation, still on the same page in the B/C/S, Rajko Kalabic informed
25 those present on the issues considered in the second part of the Serbian
Page 9948
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12 Blank page inserted to ensure pagination corresponds between the French and
13 English transcripts.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Page 9949
1 Assembly proceedings. There was a session of the Serbian Assembly on the
2 21st of December. So we see the channel of communication, the way -- as
3 described in the Assembly sessions before, that the deputies convey
4 information to the municipality. We see Kalabic doing that.
5 On the same page in the translation, and the next page in the
6 B/C/S, 00914530 -- oh, I'm sorry. I'm trying to avoid the highlighted
7 section. Pardon me.
8 One member asks that the meeting be informed about the second
9 stage, and Kalabic said: "The first stage is the preparation for the
10 second stage so there is no need to introduce the second stage," another
11 reference consistent with the 19 December instructions.
12 JUDGE ORIE: May I ask one question. If you say that "Rajko
13 Kalabic informed those present on the issues considered in the second part
14 of the Serbian Assembly proceedings" what is that exactly, the second
15 part?
16 THE WITNESS: The original says -- yes, the second part. I'm just
17 seeing where it says the "pauza". It says, if I read the B/C/S just to
18 see if the order of words makes anything more clear. This is on 00914529.
19 [Interpretation] "The second part of the Serbian Assembly, after
20 the break, the presidents were informed by Kalabic Rajko."
21 [In English] As to what they mean -- whether it means simply the
22 part after the break -- whether the break was in the Assembly session that
23 he's reporting on or in the -- this meeting here, it's not entirely clear.
24 But I'm not familiar enough with the proceedings of that Assembly session
25 to say that it was divided in two, or anything like that.
Page 9950
1 JUDGE ORIE: Yes.
2 MR. HANNIS: Thank you.
3 Q. Anything else on that document before I show you the next one?
4 A. No, that's all.
5 Q. Next, we'll have a look at presentation tab 243, master tab 148,
6 which is a report on the work of the Crisis Staff in Kljuc.
7 A. Yes, report -- we see such reports in a few municipalities. We
8 just talked about the Krupa one already. These are generally -- the ones
9 I've seen appear to be at the first meeting of the municipal assembly
10 after the war operations, when the Crisis Staff is now supposed to -- or
11 War Presidency, supposed to cease operations and the municipal assembly
12 take over. There seems to have been, in several cases, a report given on
13 what they had done in the interim, and this appears to be such a one.
14 It's dated the 29th of July, so it covers the period from the 15th of May
15 to the 29th of July.
16 I'll just give the usher all of the pages, I'm sorry.
17 It notes on the first page that the Crisis Staff was established
18 in the SDS on the 23rd of December, as we saw in that minute. That, "In
19 mid-May, it was expanded and transformed into the Crisis Staff of the
20 municipal assembly." Again, to replace the municipal assembly, this is
21 the pattern I've described in my report, noting that, as it moves from the
22 SDS organ to the municipal organ, it does add some new members,
23 representative of its wider role as the municipal authority.
24 It says: "It was the supreme organ of authority with all the
25 prerogatives of the Assembly. It adopted all decisions and conclusions
Page 9951
1 falling within the jurisdiction of the Assembly."
2 It then became the War Presidency on the 31st of May, and it's --
3 okay. Yes, on page 3 in the translation, still on the first page of the
4 report, in the B/C/S, 00349533, just a note on how it worked, that it
5 based its activities on collective work; that sessions were held in the
6 beginning every day and generally twice a week.
7 On the next page of the B/C/S, the first paragraph, an important
8 reference to cooperation with the army; that representatives regularly
9 participated in the sessions; maintained good cooperation and coordination
10 with the Crisis Staff. "All major questions related to the army and
11 police were resolved within the Crisis Staff of the municipal assembly,"
12 and notes "This is a period of very successful cooperation between the
13 Crisis Staff and military organs in crushing armed resistance by Muslim
14 extremists." So an example of the cooperation I talked about.
15 The last paragraph on the same page in the B/C/S, 00349534, page 4
16 in the translation, the report notes: "Certain negative trends which were
17 not compatible with the dignity of the Serbian people; certain
18 paramilitary groups and individuals appeared who engaged in looting,
19 torching, and attacks mostly in settlements, villages, inhabited by
20 Muslims after hostilities had ceased and the terrain had been mopped up,
21 and in breaking and moving into empty apartments."
22 The word for mopping up is "ciscenje terena." I take "ciscenje
23 terena" to be specifically the mopping up of the terrain.
24 The next page in the B/C/S, 00349535, just again describing how it
25 worked; that it discussed and analysed military, security and political
Page 9952
1 situation, and adopted orders, decisions, and conclusions.
2 Page 5 in the translation, same page in the B/C/S, third
3 paragraph, mention of -- dealing with personnel issues in the judiciary,
4 public prosecutor's office, and other -- the administrative organs, public
5 and socially-owned enterprises. "Questions related to the organised
6 moving out of Muslims and the question of the status of Muslim citizens
7 were often dealt with, and conclusions were adopted on these issues at
8 Crisis Staff sessions." So all the various topics that I have discussed
9 in my report. It's nice when they write a report for me and summarise
10 their work.
11 Last paragraph on the translation, first paragraph on 00349536,
12 talks about the role of the Crisis Staff and War Presidency in
13 establishing and equipping the 17th Infantry Brigade. So a summary of
14 their work indicates that the way they -- in which they worked, and the
15 topics they dealt with.
16 Q. Thank you. The next tab, 24 --
17 MR. HANNIS: Yes, Your Honour.
18 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] May I ask a question? Why was
19 such a report drawn up? Was it for archive purposes or was -- why was
20 this report drawn up? Was it meant to be sent to higher-ups in the
21 hierarchy? Do we know anything about this? Because if I understand you
22 correctly, you found these type of reports in other municipal assemblies.
23 THE WITNESS: My understanding of this report is that it would be
24 written for the municipal assembly. When it would first meet, the
25 municipality -- it did not meet during this time period. The Crisis
Page 9953
1 Staff/War Presidency took over all responsibilities and competencies of
2 the municipal assembly. When the municipal assembly could meet again, it
3 would confirm the decisions that had been passed in its name, confirmed or
4 not, although the records I've seen, they confirm generally everything.
5 Sometimes they asked for clarification. And I take this to be such a
6 report presented to the municipal assembly, because we also see a list of
7 all the decisions taken by the Crisis Staff and War Presidency, and the
8 municipal assembly would then consider them all. That's my understanding
9 of this report.
10 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Thank you, Witness.
11 MR. HANNIS: Next tab, 244, Your Honour, we'll skip. It's some
12 discussion about a shortage of weapons and training.
13 Q. Tab 245, Ms. Hanson, I'd like to show you, master tab 283. This
14 is a document from the military, dated the 4th of May, 1992.
15 A. Yes, from the command of the 3rd Partizan Division to the
16 commander of the 5th Corps, a regular combat report.
17 Q. And does it have some reference to the Kljuc Crisis Staff?
18 A. Yes, it does, and to the themes I had mentioned of some of the
19 military issues. On the first page -- well, actually, I don't believe
20 that's my highlighting.
21 Q. The one you wanted to talk about appears on the second page.
22 A. Yes, second page, 6, state of morale. That's on the second page
23 of the B/C/S, 00954740, at the bottom third of the page 6.
24 Under the question of morale, this report notes that: "Serbian
25 extremism is increasingly present in Kljuc induced by the official organs
Page 9954
1 of authority since the president of the municipality is asking to have his
2 own army which he would use as he sees fit."
3 The president of the municipality was Jovo Banjac, member of the
4 Crisis Staff. I'm sorry, I'm getting confused with the names. We'll see
5 in the other documents the president of the municipality and the president
6 of the Crisis Staff.
7 Q. Veljko Kondic?
8 A. Yes, thank you. A few too many names, Your Honour.
9 Q. Could you tell us his name again?
10 A. Veljko Kondic.
11 Q. All right. Do you see in the documentation anything about that
12 event that was being discussed, or how the JNA reacted to it?
13 A. Of this particular thing, not -- not this event in Kljuc. I'm
14 not ...
15 Q. Okay, thank you. Let me now talk about the police, which was
16 another topic we've discussed before with regard to the Crisis Staffs, and
17 I'll hand you presentation tab 246, master tab 183, from the 7th of May.
18 A. Yes. An announcement of the Kljuc municipal Crisis Staff on the
19 formation of the Serbian public security station in Kljuc. This is, of
20 course, consistent with the 19 December instructions on taking over the
21 police station. This says that the police now wear the Serbian flag and
22 patch on which the word "police" is written in Cyrillic. The Serbian flag
23 is displayed on the municipal building. The Kljuc municipality will be
24 incorporated in the Autonomous Region of Krajina and the Serbian Republic
25 of Bosnia-Herzegovina, and "therefore, the municipality is automatically
Page 9955
1 required to administer laws and decisions adopted by the Assembly of the
2 Serbian Republic of BH and the Assembly of the ARK." It notes, again,
3 further down, that all decisions is -- and work is carried out in
4 accordance with those organs.
5 And on the second page, which is on the second page of the B/C/S,
6 00914750, the underlined section in the centre: "All the citizens are
7 guaranteed all civil rights and freedoms, regardless of their religious or
8 ethnic background, provided that they respect the authorities."
9 So the authority -- the Crisis Staff is setting itself up as the
10 authority and demanding respect and guaranteeing rights in return.
11 Q. Thank you. Let me go next to presentation tab 247, master tab
12 202. This is from a Crisis Staff meeting on the 13th and 14th of May,
13 1992.
14 A. Yes. Here, I take you to agenda item 2, the adoption of positions
15 in connection with the decisions of the Serbian Assembly of BH. As you'll
16 recall, there was a session on the 12th of May of the Serbian Assembly.
17 On the second page, under item 2, we see that Jovo Banjac,
18 president of the Crisis Staff, and Rajko Kalabic, deputy of the Assembly,
19 discuss the security situation "in connection with the decisions and
20 reports of the session of the Serbian Republic of BH Assembly." And the
21 Crisis Staff adopted a report in connection with the decisions of that
22 Assembly. So more indications of the communications from the Assembly to
23 the municipality, and the municipal support for the Assembly decisions.
24 Q. All right. In addition to these minutes of that meeting, did you
25 have some other document referring to what took place in regard to that
Page 9956
1 discussion?
2 A. Yes. As I mentioned, we have a copy of the diary of the secretary
3 of the Crisis Staff, which also has minutes of this meeting.
4 Q. Let me refer you, then, to tab 248 in the presentation, master
5 binder number 13. And in the original, this is a handwritten document, so
6 could you refer us to which portions you're referring to.
7 A. The first reference is the B/C/S 01399464, and it -- agenda for a
8 meeting of the Crisis Staff on the 14th of May. The items, "the
9 separation of the Serbian ethnic community from ..." it is a handwritten
10 document so some parts are illegible. "Creation of our territory and a
11 transversal - the corridor; borders on the Una and Neretva; division of
12 Sarajevo; access to the sea." Those are all consistent with the strategic
13 objectives. Here it is notable that they do not have reference to the
14 Drina, which was one of the strategic objectives. But I would point out
15 that Kljuc is quite far from the Drina.
16 But this indicates that the strategic objectives, as discussed at
17 the 12th of May session, were conveyed to the municipal level. Other
18 items here are also consistent with the 12th of May session that the --
19 the establishment of the VRS, the army under the command of the
20 Presidency, also anthem, borders and taxes, those are all mentioned in the
21 12th of May session.
22 Q. Next --
23 A. Also, from this diary, another meeting of the Crisis Staff.
24 Q. Yes. If you want to refer to that while we have the diary there.
25 A. This is on the B/C/S 01399467 and the following page. A note
Page 9957
1 under -- that's not the right page for you. It's 19 and 20. Page 19 in
2 the translation, on item 2 in the agenda, "political and security
3 situation - Telexes." On the next page, in a moment, we'll see what the
4 telexes might have been about. I'd draw your attention to a list of the
5 make-up of the Crisis Staff. President is Jovo Banjac and Veljko Kondic
6 is the deputy president. Also, a lieutenant colonel, Milojevic is listed,
7 as is the assembly deputy, Rajko Kalabic.
8 On the next page, 01399468 in the translation -- in the B/C/S,
9 indication of communications from higher levels. Veljko Kondic read out
10 the telexes from the Bosnian Krajina, and R. Karadzic. Then they
11 discussed mobilisation, including mobilising all Muslims to report. Then
12 I note that the telexes would be photocopied and copies sent to the
13 police, the TO, president of the assembly, an indication of the orders
14 being passed from -- received from Karadzic and from, apparently, the ARK
15 level and then distributed -- passed further on to the municipality for
16 implementation.
17 Q. Anything else from that before we go on?
18 A. No, that's all from that document.
19 Q. Thank you.
20 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, I intended to skip the next tabs, 249
21 and, 250, and 251, and go to tab 252, which is master tab 79.
22 Q. This is an excerpt from the book of minutes of the Kljuc municipal
23 assembly Crisis Staff. Ms. Hanson, I think we had particularly taken note
24 of items 1 through 3, 10 through 13, and 18 and 19, on these pages.
25 A. I would just like to point out that, for some reason, the pages of
Page 9958
1 this book of minutes were stamped out of order, so the ERNs of the
2 original will jump around. But if you look at the -- if you read each
3 page carefully, they can be put together in the order that they are.
4 There might be a little confusion because of that, and because, of course,
5 the translation sometimes takes less -- is more -- translation covers many
6 pages just because it's more neatly written.
7 But this is beginning on 00573857. Under item 2, we see -- sorry,
8 item 1, a reference to the Crisis Staff of the ARK, affirming the
9 legitimacy of the ARK Crisis Staff. Two, judicial appointments, again
10 proposing judges and prosecutor. Item 3, replacing all non-Serbian
11 personnel in various posts "where independent decision-making is possible
12 and the protection of properties ..." So dismissal of non-Serbs.
13 Under -- at the next page of the translation, at the bottom of the
14 next page in the B/C/S, 00573858, a nice explication -- the Crisis Staff
15 is explicating the relationship between the military and the civilian.
16 "The military authorities will follow the orders of the civilian
17 authorities. The civilian authorities will not interfere with the way
18 they are followed."
19 Then under item 11, which is on the next page, in the B/C/S,
20 00573859. "Establishment of an agency for the reception/removal of
21 refugees from one region to another." Number 12, "Prohibit the return of
22 families that have departed if those families did so without appropriate
23 reasons." Also mobilisation, a discussion. Number 18, which is on the
24 next page in the B/C/S, 00573860: "The municipal Crisis Staff adopted the
25 decision on the organisation of departure from the area of the
Page 9959
1 municipality. The departure of individuals from the municipality will be
2 organised by the municipal secretariat of national defence."
3 Then the last -- well, I didn't even get it on there. Yes, I'm
4 sorry. Under -- it's a moment where the B/C/S does not follow
5 immediately, but I believe it is 00573874. I'll confirm that in a moment.
6 The Crisis Staff is appointing battalion command personnel, and so on, so
7 more indication of the Crisis Staff appointing military personnel.
8 Q. Okay.
9 JUDGE ORIE: Do we have that page in the --
10 THE WITNESS: Yes, I'm sorry, it's --
11 JUDGE ORIE: -- B/C/S?
12 THE WITNESS: Yes. It's the next tab, actually, because it is --
13 it's 00573882. It's where -- the interruption jumps from 60 to 82.
14 Because that page also contains the 28th of May announcement, it's
15 entered, I guess, as a separate --
16 JUDGE ORIE: My question was -- oh, yes, the previous one was 81,
17 last two digits of the ERN number, and that --
18 THE WITNESS: No.
19 JUDGE ORIE: The previous one we saw?
20 THE WITNESS: Of the B/C/S?
21 JUDGE ORIE: Yes.
22 THE WITNESS: 00573860.
23 JUDGE ORIE: And the second one?
24 THE WITNESS: 00573882.
25 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Please proceed.
Page 9960
1 THE WITNESS: That's all for this session, as I say. That page
2 also includes the next session, but that's another tab.
3 MR. HANNIS:
4 Q. I wanted to skip a couple of tabs, 253 and 254, and take you to
5 tab 255 in the presentation, which is master tab 82. And this refers to
6 the meeting of the 29th of May.
7 A. This is in the B/C/S 00573883 and 3884. First sentence, just to
8 note that the Crisis Staff is in continuous session. That same paragraph,
9 at the end: "The transport of the Muslim members of Territorial Defence
10 to Stari Gradiska has been secured."
11 And under item 3, which is on the second page of the B/C/S,
12 discussing the mopping up of two areas of town - in the original it's
13 simply "ciscenje" - to be carried out by the police. So the Crisis Staff
14 ordering the police to carry out the ciscenje.
15 Q. Next, presentation tab 256, master tab 83, and I believe it begins
16 on the bottom of that first page. It's a meeting from the 30th of May,
17 1992. I'll get to you comment on some items on the second page in the
18 English.
19 A. This begins in the B/C/S 00573885. I'd note that the unit
20 commander was at the session of the Crisis Staff, and his decision to
21 block the villages of Ramici, Plamenice, Vukova Sela, Krasulje and Kaliska
22 was accepted, with the obligation of calling for the unconditional
23 surrender and surrender of arms. And then, if no resistance is given, the
24 mopping up of the area can be carried out. It is "ciscenje terene."
25 Item 2, which goes onto the next page of the B/C/S, 00573886, that
Page 9961
1 the police carry out the mopping up - again, "ciscenje terene" is mopping
2 up - and according to the plans as set, and to carry out the return of
3 weapons. So there's a plan for the ciscenje terene, mopping up of some
4 towns -- areas of the -- towns, yes.
5 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, let me skip the next tab, presentation
6 tab 257, and go to presentation 258, master tab 85, for a meeting on the
7 2nd of June.
8 A. This is, in the B/C/S, 00573890. Notable here under item 1, that
9 the brigade commander reports to the Crisis Staff. And then under (b),
10 the chief of police reports to the Crisis Staff on the operations of the
11 police in mopping up the area, on processing those arrested, and on the
12 security of the town. It is "ciscenje terene," mopping of the area.
13 Q. Thank you. Next, presentation tab 259, master tab 86. This is a
14 meeting on the following day, the 3rd of June, and in particular, items
15 number 4 and 7.
16 A. This is, in the B/C/S, 00573891, and on to the next page. Item 4,
17 "the question of the removal of the population." And item 7, the problem
18 or the "issue of prisoners."
19 I would point out that the discussion of those agenda items is
20 missing from the pages of the book. We did not seem to receive them.
21 Some pages are out of order, but the pages that correspond to those agenda
22 items are not there.
23 Q. Yes. To the first four items --
24 A. The first four items, yes.
25 Q. Was there a discussion of item number 7 regarding prisoners?
Page 9962
1 A. Yes. And that is the next page, as stamped 00573892. On the
2 issue of prisoners, the chief of police indicated to the Crisis Staff the
3 problem of prisoners, the greatest problem being their accommodation.
4 Q. Thank you.
5 JUDGE ORIE: I have some difficulties in following this. You said
6 the discussion on item number 2 regarding prisoners was at ERN number,
7 last two digits, 92. I couldn't find them that quickly, because under tab
8 258, it stops at 891. Should I look at the next one? But then I have
9 difficulty --
10 THE WITNESS: Well, 3891 appears twice. One, for the first half
11 of the page, referring to the previous session, that's the previous tab --
12 JUDGE ORIE: Yes.
13 THE WITNESS: -- but the tab, the document we're looking at now,
14 it's the same page, 3891, in reference to the session of the 3rd of June.
15 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, that's, in the translation, page number 10 at
16 the bottom.
17 THE WITNESS: Yes.
18 JUDGE ORIE: And where, now, do we see the -- agenda item 7
19 discussed?
20 THE WITNESS: Yes. At 00573892.
21 JUDGE ORIE: I'm -- I take it that there is a numbered translation
22 as well. Would that be on page --
23 THE WITNESS: Page 11 of the translation.
24 JUDGE ORIE: And under what tab do I find that?
25 MR. HANNIS: I think the B/C/S for that page 92 was actually
Page 9963
1 behind tab 259.
2 JUDGE ORIE: Okay. So we move to the next tab.
3 THE WITNESS: I've been in 259.
4 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, I've found it. Perhaps I failed to follow you.
5 THE WITNESS: I had difficulty myself putting the translation
6 together with each session. It's very difficult.
7 JUDGE ORIE: You said "I couldn't find them that quickly because,
8 under tab 258 --" Then you said, "Should I look at the next one," but
9 then you had a difficulty -- no, that was me, myself. Well, I'm there,
10 that's the most important.
11 MR. HANNIS: Thank you. And to everyone's relief, I hope, we'll
12 skip tabs 260 through 263, because mostly those are just to reflect
13 reports from the police, the army, and the TO, and go to tab 264 in the
14 presentation, which is master tab 91.
15 Q. If you could talk about a meeting on June the 6th and June the
16 9th.
17 A. Yes. The B/C/S is 00573870. The top of the page, which is from
18 the 6th of June session, on page 14 in the translation, the third item:
19 "The status and employment of Muslim citizens should be resolved on the
20 regional level across the board." Then skipping the next item. "The
21 matter of the organised removal of the Muslim population should be
22 resolved." And lastly, skipping another sentence, the last sentence:
23 "Nothing should be done to the Muslim population in areas where it is not
24 necessary." And still on the same page in both the translation and the
25 B/C/S, the 9th of June session, noting a report on the condition of
Page 9964
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12 Blank page inserted to ensure pagination corresponds between the French and
13 English transcripts.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Page 9965
1 prisoners as number -- as item number 1.
2 Q. Okay, thank you. Anything else from that one?
3 A. Yes. On page 15 on to 16 in the translation, and I'm just
4 checking the B/C/S, 00573871 on the B/C/S, about three-quarters of the way
5 down, "the question of the employment of Muslims" seems to be referring to
6 the earlier decision on managerial posts and important posts concerning
7 property and information.
8 Agenda item 4, in the B/C/S 00573872, discussing the status and
9 the inclusion of Muslims and Croats in the health authorities, and the
10 need to take a specific stand on this issue.
11 Q. Okay.
12 JUDGE ORIE: May I ask one question?
13 THE WITNESS: Mm-hm.
14 JUDGE ORIE: This Chamber has understood the case of the
15 Prosecution to be that many of the actions undertaken were actions to make
16 certain municipalities and areas purely Serb. You just highlighted a line
17 which says, "nothing should be done to the Muslim population in areas
18 where it is not necessary." Does that mean that these were areas which
19 were not aimed at becoming purely Serb in this municipality, or is this
20 contradicting, to that extent, the Prosecution's case that the aim in many
21 areas was to make it purely Serb? I tried to understand how, in this
22 decision -- it seems to say, if you don't need it, let the Muslim
23 population, let them -- well, if not be in peace, at least be.
24 THE WITNESS: There are several factors which might --
25 JUDGE ORIE: If you say it's beyond your expertise, then please
Page 9966
1 tell us.
2 THE WITNESS: Well, I can't know exactly what they mean here in
3 Kljuc and what areas they refer to. But it is notable in -- from these
4 minutes that there are discussions of disarming of Muslims and some
5 resistance to disarming. We don't know where -- what areas they say it
6 isn't necessary. But that might be one of the criteria, because that is a
7 common theme. Another would be -- I'm thinking of, here, also the
8 document we looked at not long ago where the representatives of several
9 municipalities, including Kljuc, said that Muslim population or non-Serb
10 population should be moved out to a level at which Serbian authority can
11 be maintained. And some areas might be more Muslim-settled and less Serb,
12 but there -- in all these municipalities, no settlement was ever entirely,
13 or practically no settlement was entirely Serb or entirely one nation --
14 one ethnic group.
15 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. You've heard the question.
16 MR. HANNIS: Yes.
17 JUDGE ORIE: And I take it that -- well, being aware that it leads
18 to -- it was a question that arose, that to the extent you intend to
19 present any further evidence on that, we'll hear that, if it comes to
20 that.
21 MR. HANNIS: Yes, Your Honour. And I know this is not time to
22 make argument; we'll address that much later.
23 JUDGE ORIE: No.
24 MR. HANNIS:
25 Q. Let me move on, then, to tab 266, which is master tab 29 -- is
Page 9967
1 master tab 93. This is a meeting of the 16th of June, and I'd like you to
2 mention or discuss items 1, 3, and 7 in that meeting.
3 A. Yes. This is, on the B/C/S, 00573873, and the next page. Agenda
4 item 1, appointing the brigade commander, saying it should be resolved by,
5 pardon me, the 18th of June, noting this is still into June -- yes, sorry.
6 I apologise, I seem to be in the wrong tab. I gave the wrong B/C/S, my
7 apologies. Or did I? This is, by far, the worst set of documents for the
8 case studies. It will get easier. I don't want to see that; it doesn't
9 help.
10 Q. I know the date of the meeting is on the preceding English page,
11 but the substance is on that first page you have.
12 A. I see, I see. Yes. I don't seem to have the B/C/S pages in front
13 of me, so I can't give the ERN.
14 Q. Items 3 and 7, at any rate, are on 00573861.
15 A. Thank you.
16 Q. I don't know if item 1 would be on the immediately preceding page.
17 A. Yes, 74. This is where the confusion arises. Yes, item 1 is on
18 00573874, on appointing the brigade commander, and item 3 is --
19 Q. Item 3 and 7 appear to be on 00573861.
20 A. Yes, thank you. It is a confusion. "The Crisis Staff shall
21 remain the highest authority and will cooperate fully with the military
22 command and the Kljuc SJB."
23 Item 7 on the same page, that "a work group should review the
24 situation regarding managerial posts held by Muslims, and to propose new
25 personnel solutions."
Page 9968
1 Q. Thank you. Now we'll skip some tabs 267 through 271, and go to
2 presentation tab 272, master tab 99. Those tabs we skipped are footnotes
3 in your report.
4 JUDGE ORIE: Just drawing the attention to the fact that it might
5 be a bit confusing now for Mr. Krajisnik, because the issue under agenda
6 item 1 about the appointment of the brigade commander does not appear in
7 the original under the same tab number, 266, but does appear under -- the
8 original, under tab 265.
9 MR. HANNIS: The preceding tab, that's right, Your Honour.
10 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Whereas it does not appear in the translation
11 under tab 265, as far as I can see.
12 MR. HANNIS: No, it's not. It's --
13 JUDGE ORIE: So it's a bit confusing, and I'd like you to
14 specifically tell us not only what ERN number the original can be found,
15 but also so under what tab number, so that Mr. Krajisnik is able to find
16 it. But, of course, the Chamber prefers to have the translation under the
17 same tab number as the original is.
18 MR. HANNIS: We do too, Your Honour. This is the last one in
19 connection with that last handwritten document, and hopefully it will go
20 smoother after this one.
21 THE WITNESS: It will.
22 MR. HANNIS:
23 Q. In this one, Ms. Hanson, I wanted you to refer to the meeting of
24 the 26th -- the 10th of July.
25 A. The 10th of July, that's 00573879, noting the adoption of the
Page 9969
1 decision on the establishment of a War Presidency. So we see the Crisis
2 Staff becoming a War Presidency in July.
3 Q. And on that same page, I believe in both the B/C/S and English --
4 JUDGE ORIE: Which tab are we at this moment?
5 MR. HANNIS: This is tab 272, Your Honour.
6 JUDGE ORIE: 272.
7 MR. HANNIS: Yes. We skipped several.
8 JUDGE ORIE: We skipped, yes.
9 MR. HANNIS: 267 through 271.
10 JUDGE ORIE: 10th of July, I've got that. Yes, and I see that all
11 is in the original under the same tab, at least the 10th of July. Please
12 proceed.
13 MR. HANNIS:
14 Q. And right above that, on the English page, and I believe also in
15 the B/C/S, in discussing matters in the previous meeting --
16 A. Yes, the previous meeting. "The question of the status of Muslim
17 citizens and further work employment." The municipal Crisis Staff refers
18 this decision to what they term the Banja Luka regional Crisis Staff, a
19 reference, I take it, to ARK, the ARK Crisis Staff.
20 Q. Thank you. Let's finish with that one, then, and I'll take you to
21 presentation tab 273, master tab 152. And can you tell us what this is?
22 A. Yes. This is, in B/C/S, 00575222, a review of decisions,
23 conclusions, rulings, and orders issued by the Crisis Staff and War
24 Presidency -- War Presidency. In the translation it says "the Crisis
25 Staff of the War Presidency," but if we just put the B/C/S on the screen,
Page 9970
1 you can see it's just a hyphen, if that's helpful.
2 Q. Okay. And I see you highlighted some particular items on that
3 list. Can you tell us about those, please?
4 A. I pointed out the hyphen just to show that it's seen as a --
5 essentially the same body. Yes, there's some interesting decisions here.
6 I take this document to be connected to the report that we saw. In other
7 municipalities, we have seen this kind of list submitted to the municipal
8 assembly for their review and confirmation. There's no indication on this
9 document that that was its purpose, but it's consistent with that.
10 If we look at decisions 12, 13, 14, 16, and 17, they are decisions
11 on judicial dismissals and appointments; 18, establishing a War
12 Presidency; 21, financing the army, paying a sum to the army; 23, a
13 committee for the receipt of war and other booty; 26, which is on the next
14 page, in the B/C/S, 00575223, a decision on members of the War Presidency
15 to -- allowing them to carry weapons and wear uniforms, which I think is
16 indicative of their -- the military role in which they -- that they gave
17 themselves, or they saw themselves as having. On the next page in the
18 translation, 29, reinforcing the infantry brigade. Then the last -- from
19 31 onward, decisions on municipal appointments and dismissals, or in this
20 case just dismissals; decision on positions that can only be filled by
21 workers of Serbian nationality; and the last item, "committee for the
22 collection of data relating to the population exodus from the territory of
23 Kljuc municipality."
24 Q. Thank you.
25 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, I'm going to skip several tabs, 274 and
Page 9971
1 275, relating to freedom of movement, and they are footnoted documents to
2 the report. 276 to 280 regard dismissal from municipal employment.
3 Q. And I would like to go to 281, which is master tab 131. This is
4 from -- a decision from the 10th of July, I believe, or the 13th. I'm not
5 sure.
6 A. Well, the session was held on the 10th, and the date on the
7 published decision is the 13th. This is the B/C/S 00575284. Notable in
8 the preamble, that they take this decision to form the War Presidency, on
9 the basis of Article 2 of the decision on the formation of War
10 Presidencies in municipalities during imminent threat of war or state of
11 war. I take that to be a reference to the Presidency decision of 31 May.
12 As we saw, according to the 10th of June decision, that 31 May
13 decision was superseded by the later decision. But you can see that on
14 the ground, the municipalities -- this municipality, at least, still took
15 its decision to form a War Presidency on the basis of that Presidency
16 decision. Clearly, the War Presidency is replacing the Crisis Staff; it
17 says it's formed instead of the Crisis Staff. The makeup is almost
18 identical to the Crisis Staff, as listed in the 18 May entry of Bajic's
19 diary. Certainly, the essential members, the same Jovo Banjac, president;
20 Veljko Kondic, deputy president. Item 7, Rajko Kalabic, the Assembly
21 deputy is a member; 8 and 9, the head of the police station and the
22 secretary of the SDS; and lastly, number 12, the commander of the brigade.
23 Q. Thank you. Let me show you next presentation tab 28 --
24 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, I'm going to skip 282, which is the
25 decision she mentioned before regarding War Presidency members carrying
Page 9972
1 weapons and uniforms -- and wearing uniforms.
2 Q. Tab 283 in the presentation is master tab 313, from the 21st of
3 July. Can you tell us about that one?
4 A. The B/C/S, 00914877, a decision that only Serbs can hold positions
5 -- managerial positions or positions where the inflow of information is
6 important, and all places of importance for protecting socially-owned
7 property and the functioning of economic entities. Then they specify,
8 sort of, "all socially-owned enterprises, shareholding companies, state
9 institutions, public enterprises, and the police station."
10 Item 3, similarly, Serbs who are not loyal to the Serb Republic --
11 Serbian Republic, cannot fill those positions either.
12 Q. Thank you.
13 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, might this be a good time for the next
14 break?
15 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, it is. We will adjourn for 20 minutes. We will
16 resume at 10 minutes to 1.00.
17 --- Recess taken at 12.30 p.m.
18 --- On resuming at 12.58 p.m.
19 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, Mr. Krajisnik has some query, which I'm
20 not able to understand, just about a specific -- apparently about a
21 specific piece of material. I'm not quite sure who the query is addressed
22 to. I wonder, with Your Honours' indulgence, if he can just put it and
23 then we'll know who the query is addressed to.
24 JUDGE ORIE: Yes.
25 MR. STEWART: That's very kind. Thank you, Your Honour.
Page 9973
1 JUDGE ORIE: Especially in the absence of Ms. Cmeric, I'll be a
2 bit more flexible. Please ask what you're going to ask. Would it be a
3 question for the witness or for us or ...
4 THE ACCUSED: [Interpretation] No. I just asked this lady to find
5 me a file. It's an electronic piece of evidence. I gave her a number but
6 I'm afraid we didn't understand each other well, me not speaking English.
7 I have the number.
8 [Trial Chamber and registrar confer]
9 JUDGE ORIE: Sometimes, Mr. Krajisnik, communication is not that
10 easy. I think Ms. Philpott understood that you were looking for that
11 document, and she passed the request to the OTP case manager, and as soon
12 as it has been found and printed, you will receive the copy.
13 MR. STEWART: Thank you, Your Honour. I did understand it was a
14 practical matter, and I'm grateful for that.
15 JUDGE ORIE: There is another matter before I allow you to resume
16 your examination-in-chief, Mr. Hannis.
17 I indicated before that the Chamber would try to give a decision,
18 an oral decision, in a couple of days on the motion for adjournment.
19 Since the Chamber could not decide the matter before, I would say, the
20 e-mail exchange of the parties was finished, before we knew about the
21 result of that, meanwhile, the Chamber worked hard on a draft decision in
22 writing, because the matter was important enough to have it in writing. I
23 can inform the parties that our decision will be filed this afternoon, in
24 writing. It's now undergoing the final checks on formalities, but the
25 decision is there, and in the decision, the motion is denied. But that's
Page 9974
1 what's going to be filed this afternoon so that the parties are aware of
2 it.
3 Then, Mr. Hannis, please proceed.
4 MR. HANNIS: Thank you, Your Honour. I think we left off with tab
5 283. I intend to skip tabs 284 through 288. They all pertain to
6 dismissals of Muslims from employment, I believe, in the municipality, and
7 they're referred to in the report. I would note that 287 refers to Asim
8 Egeric and 288 refers to Omer Filipovic, who were gentlemen we heard about
9 during testimony about Kljuc municipality earlier in the case, and Mr.
10 Filipovic who died in Manjaca.
11 Q. Tab 289 is the next one I'd like to go to, Ms. Hanson, it's master
12 tab 349. It's a decision of the War Presidency, dated the 30th of July, I
13 believe.
14 A. Yes. The decision of the War Presidency on the criteria required
15 in order to move out of Kljuc municipality. We saw one earlier from
16 Sanski Most. And just to show it has similar criteria, under article 1,
17 that "families and persons who issue a statement ... declaring that they
18 are moving permanently from the territory shall be permitted to leave,"
19 again, the exchange of real estate or placing properties, at the disposal
20 of the municipalities permitted, under Article 2, but the sale of property
21 is not allowed.
22 Q. Thank you. In relation to that, can I show you tab 290 in the
23 presentation, master tab 351.
24 A. This is a record dated the 31st of July, a statement by Camil
25 Kuburas, that he is leaving Kljuc permanently and voluntarily. At the
Page 9975
1 bottom of the translation, and on to the second page of the translation,
2 he says that he "has been informed of the order of the War Presidency of
3 Kljuc on the criteria for the possibility of permanent departure of 30
4 July," and he states that he is leaving Kljuc voluntarily and permanently.
5 And he registers the house that he has in Kljuc.
6 Q. Thank you. That concludes our case study on Kljuc. Now, if we
7 could turn to Trnovo --
8 JUDGE ORIE: Could I ask one question?
9 MR. HANNIS: Yes.
10 JUDGE ORIE: I did see under tab 289 that the conditions for
11 leaving included the possibility to take all movable property, although
12 they needed to have an inventory of those -- of that movable property. It
13 doesn't say anything about 300 Deutschemarks. But I had to check first
14 whether this was before or after, but I couldn't find it that quickly.
15 THE WITNESS: The 300 Deutschemarks that I noted before was from
16 Kotor Varos, and at the moment I don't recall that we had seen that amount
17 specified in Kljuc. If we --
18 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, I'm looking for that tab number.
19 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. I just wanted to consult it, but I've not found
20 it.
21 THE WITNESS: But it would be -- this document would be after
22 anything we saw from Kljuc, because it's dated the 31st of July.
23 MR. HANNIS: It's tab 230, Your Honour, and it was from Kotor
24 Varos.
25 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Please proceed. Please proceed. I'll find it
Page 9976
1 again.
2 MR. HANNIS: All right, thank you.
3 Q. Then, turning to Trnovo, I'd like to hand you presentation tab
4 291, which is master tab number 10. This is from a meeting on the 25th of
5 December, 1991.
6 A. Minutes of the meeting of the Trnovo SDS municipal board on the
7 25th of December. We have seen this document at the beginning of the
8 presentation on the receipt and implementation of the 19 December
9 instructions, and just now looking at Trnovo as a whole to see -- they did
10 receive these instructions by the 25th of December. It appears because
11 agenda item 1 is directives referring to organising Serbian people in
12 crisis situations, and the meeting sets up a duty roster, sets up a Crisis
13 Staff. And here we know Glisa Simanic is suggested as a coordinator.
14 He's a character we will see in these minutes, and you'll recall the
15 intercepted conversation between Glisa Simanic and General Ratko Mladic.
16 Q. Thank you. And following on that, two days later, presentation
17 tab 292, master tab number 44, another meeting in Trnovo.
18 A. Minutes of the meeting of the Trnovo SDS municipal board on the
19 27th of December. In the B/C/S, 02280490, the lower half of the page. It
20 notes that: "On the basis of the instructions for organisation of the
21 Serbian people," they name the members of the secretariat as members of
22 the Crisis Staff, along with officials in the municipal assembly, saying
23 that the Assembly will appoint a Crisis Staff and Radivoje Draskovic, who
24 was president of the SDS Trnovo, is nominated for the post of president,
25 and Glisa Simanic was appointed coordinator for crisis situations. This
Page 9977
1 is the document we pointed out last time. The translation reads, although
2 it's Simanic.
3 Q. I would like to 293, which is master tab 451. This is to indicate
4 that their actions are being taken based on the variant A and variant B
5 instructions.
6 A. Yes. This is a decision of the Crisis Staff of the 5th of July,
7 1992. I would just like to explain something on this document, that --
8 the heading says "Serbian Municipality of Ilidza Crisis Staff," but the
9 preamble shows it as the Crisis Staff of Trnovo. At this point, Trnovo
10 seems to have -- the Serbian part of Trnovo has attached itself, become
11 part -- fallen under the Serbian municipality of Ilidza, but it is still,
12 as you see -- the commander of the Trnovo Crisis Staff is Radivoje
13 Draskovic, signing this decision.
14 What's interesting here is that it's a minor decision forming a
15 commission for haying of fields, although you'll note under Article 2,
16 it's the haying of Muslim fields and other available hayfields.
17 More interesting here is the preamble that this Crisis Staff
18 decision is taken on the basis of the instructions on the organisation and
19 work of the organs of the Serbian people in BH in extraordinary
20 circumstances, that is, the 19 December instructions. So the Crisis
21 Staff, in July 1992, is still citing the 19 December instructions as the
22 basis for its actions.
23 Q. Thank you. Next, I'd like to show you presentation tab 295,
24 master tab 448.
25 MR. HANNIS: I've skipped 294, Your Honours. It's in her report.
Page 9978
1 A. This is the minutes of a meeting of the Trnovo SDS municipal
2 board, held on 12 February 1992. On the first page of both the
3 translation and the B/C/S, 02280494, one member complains that the weapons
4 of the Serbian people had been distributed in an unsystematic way, that
5 they had been distributed to people who were not members of the SDS, and
6 that individuals had sold weapons to the Muslims. The fact that even
7 people beyond the SDS were getting weapons is an interesting complaint, to
8 me.
9 On the question of weapons, on the bottom of the page, same page
10 in the translation, and the top of the next page in the B/C/S, 02280495,
11 Draskovic says that "a task force has been formed to provide strictly
12 confidential information about the distribution of weapons of which the
13 members of the SDS municipal board will be informed."
14 Q. Thank you.
15 MR. HANNIS: Your Honours, that's the last item in binder number
16 6. We'd like to hand around the last binder, number 7.
17 Q. And, Ms. Hanson, I'd like to hand you -- do you have binder 7?
18 A. Yes, I do.
19 Q. I'd like to begin -- I'd like to begin with presentation tab 296,
20 master tab number 226.
21 A. Minutes of a meeting of the Trnovo municipal board, on the 7th of
22 March, noting, in the centre of the page of both the original and the
23 B/C/S, that: "It has been decided to form armed units as follows: A
24 section, platoon, detachment, company, which will be ready for defence at
25 all times."
Page 9979
1 Q. Thank you. And next is presentation tab 297, which is master tab
2 459.
3 A. Yes. This is two days later, a meeting of the Crisis Staff. This
4 is the first -- earliest session of the Crisis Staff for which we have
5 minutes, connected, perhaps, to the fact that two days earlier the SDS
6 said it was decided to form armed units. The first meeting of the Crisis
7 Staff discusses what has been done regarding the organisation of the
8 command personnel. At the bottom of the page - this is all on the first
9 page of the translation and also the first page of the B/C/S - that the
10 Crisis Staff is permanently in session.
11 Q. 298 in the presentation is master tab number 450.
12 A. Another meeting of the Crisis Staff on the 20th of March -- March
13 1992. In the centre of the page, "the transformation of the municipality
14 and the local communes is to be carried out." "A decision must be carried
15 out."
16 And then number 2, "activities concerning the defence and the
17 formation of units. Battalion staff according to military principles ..."
18 And then we note again Simanic briefing the Crisis Staff on the formation
19 of units there. He notes that units have been formed in certain
20 settlements.
21 Q. Presentation 299, master tab 441, from the 24th of March, 1992.
22 A. This is a meeting of the SDS municipal board on the 24th of March,
23 noting, in the lower part of the first page of the translation, and, in
24 the B/C/S, at the top of page 02280273, Radivoje Draskovic tells the
25 municipal board that "R. Karadzic ordered the second degree of alert,
Page 9980
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12 Blank page inserted to ensure pagination corresponds between the French and
13 English transcripts.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Page 9981
1 organisation of duty shifts, guards, keep control of Serbian territory,
2 take the present situation seriously." Those who received weapons "should
3 use them for the defence of the Serbian people."
4 I would note that on this day, the 24th of March, in the Assembly,
5 we had Karadzic's speech saying that soon there will be the single method
6 applied for taking over, and that they will -- he expects them to receive
7 instructions later from the -- at the Deputy's Club. So secondary degree
8 of alert is, of course, consistent with the 19 December instructions.
9 Also, on this page, "Glisa Simanic informed those present on the
10 organisation of the Serbian command personnel." And on the second page of
11 the translation, and 02280274 in the B/C/S, some conclusions of the
12 municipal board that "Muslims should not till Serbian land, land should
13 not be sold, and taxes from farming should go into a specific account of
14 the SDS." So the SDS is diverting tax revenue into their own account.
15 Q. Thank you. Next, on the issue of coordination --
16 MR. STEWART: Excuse me, Your Honour, I wonder in this case -
17 because sometimes it's possible - where we've got illegibility in the
18 translation at the bottom of the first page, it could be that Ms. Hanson
19 is able to help us with something which has been illegible so far.
20 THE WITNESS: It's very difficult handwriting. I can take a look
21 at that page -- at that line, if that is helpful.
22 MR. HANNIS:
23 Q. Can you tell us which B/C/S we're looking at?
24 A. 02280273, fifth line up.
25 JUDGE ORIE: Could we ask you, Ms. Hanson, if you would be
Page 9982
1 provided with a copy of this page, that you look at it over the weekend,
2 and if you decipher it, that you, at the beginning of cross-examination,
3 could report it to Mr. Stewart.
4 MR. HANNIS: Thank you, Your Honour.
5 MR. STEWART: Thank you, Your Honour.
6 MR. HANNIS:
7 Q. All right. May we then go to presentation tab 300, master tab
8 212. And on the issue of coordination between Crisis Staffs, the JNA and
9 the government, can you talk to us about this 29 April 1992 meeting.
10 A. Yes. This is a meeting of the Crisis Staff on the 29th of April,
11 indicating -- in which Radivoje Draskovic reports on an agreement reached
12 with representatives of the JNA. On the B/C/S, this is 02276137,
13 Draskovic's speech in the centre of the page, bottom of the -- page 1 of
14 the translation, Draskovic says: "We have agreed with the JNA
15 representatives and they will get involved in the cleaning up of the
16 municipality, ciscenje. We have to get crews for APCs and tanks. This is
17 good for psychological effect. Work on psychological and propaganda
18 activities. We went to the government and the Serbian Ministry of
19 Interior. They gave us about 30 insignia for the police, and they agreed
20 to send a request for money, communications, equipment for the police."
21 On the top of the second page of the translation, which is on page
22 02276138 in the B/C/S, he says: "In discussion with the Prime Minister,
23 we have agreed to take whatever we can in a polite way." So contacts with
24 the government, arranging for getting support, and contacts with the JNA,
25 getting crews for APCs and tanks.
Page 9983
1 Q. Thank you. Next, I'd like to show you presentation tab 301,
2 master tab 462, dealing with the issue of support from the Republika
3 Srpska government. This is a document dated the 30th of April, I believe.
4 A. Yes, the 30th of April, a letter to the prime minister. A
5 mistranslation, again, of -- translation, Djeric. It should be Djeric,
6 not Ceric. But it notes: "In accordance with the agreement made in Pale
7 on the 28th of April, please provide us resources," and the resources
8 include 3 million dinars. So confirmation of what was in the minutes, an
9 indication of an agreement with the government and support from the
10 government.
11 Q. Do you have any information about what the agreement reached in
12 Pale on the 28th of April refers to?
13 A. The previous document, the minutes of the meeting, refer to going
14 to Pale and talking about getting resources, and doing it in the nicest
15 possible way. And this is a letter requesting it. I would take that to
16 be related.
17 MR. HANNIS: Next, tab 302, Your Honour, we'll skip it. It's just
18 establishing the use of a building for the Serbian police force in Trnovo.
19 Q. Tab 303, which is master tab number 447.
20 A. Minutes of a meeting of the Crisis Staff on the 30th of April. On
21 page, in the B/C/S, 02276142, the municipal board and Crisis Staff are
22 handing their premises over to the Serbian police station, so an
23 indication of the role of the municipal board and Crisis Staff in
24 informing the Serbian police.
25 Further down in the middle of the B/C/S page, at the bottom of
Page 9984
1 page 1 in the translation, one Crisis Staff member indicates preparations
2 for artillery activity, saying "today we will get Pero to observe the
3 terrain so that the locations are decided. From here, you cannot shell
4 Spile, but you can shell all the other villages."
5 Q. Let me next show you presentation tab 304, master tab 446, from
6 the 2nd of May.
7 A. Minutes of the Crisis Staff of the 2nd of May. Another reference
8 to military preparations. On the first page of the B/C/S, Glisa, Glisa
9 Simanic, as we know, is present, and Glisa says: "Two combat vehicles and
10 two tanks should be brought up." So the Crisis Staff is arranging for
11 getting tanks and combat vehicles.
12 Q. Presentation tab 305, master tab 105, from the 2nd of May, 1992.
13 A. This is an order of the Crisis Staff relating to freedom of
14 movement, forbidding Serbs of -- male Serbs of military age to leave the
15 territory. Interestingly enough, under point 3, the Crisis Staff says
16 that the SDS will issue permissions -- special permissions for leaving
17 temporarily, an indication, I think, of the overlap of the municipal and
18 party authorities, as well as the Crisis Staff interest in controlling
19 freedom of movement.
20 Q. Can I see on the Sanction, on the screen, that you also have the
21 seal highlighted in yellow. Did you want to comment on that?
22 A. Yes. Similarly, the Crisis Staff, which calls itself the Crisis
23 Staff of the Serbian municipality of Trnovo, uses the seal of the SDS
24 municipal board, further indication of the overlap -- of the Crisis
25 Staff's dual role as both a party organ and a government organ.
Page 9985
1 Q. Next, presentation tab 306, master tab 445.
2 A. Minutes of the Crisis Staff meeting of the 3rd of May. On the
3 first page of the translation and B/C/S, first speech by Radivoje, saying
4 that there's a lack of artillery crews, "they should get hold of crews for
5 cannons and mortar operators and send them to Kalinovik for target
6 practice." I would note that there was a JNA army base at Kalinovik.
7 Further down, in the middle of the English translation page 1, on
8 the B/C/S, the next page, 02276151, about a quarter of the way down the
9 page, Radivoje says again: "From tomorrow, one bus should go to Kalinovik
10 for target practice with artillery and infantry weapons," and then he
11 notes that they are moving into the building of the Ilidza Assembly and
12 starting the activities for the running of administrative --
13 administration organs. You know that they actually moved to Ilidza to
14 conduct their business, but claim to be the municipal authorities of
15 Trnovo.
16 On that -- it's a long meeting, with many interesting comments
17 made. Apparently, some personnel conflicts between individuals on the
18 Crisis Staff. But more important comments by Radivoje, at the bottom of
19 page 2 in the translation, and on page 02276153 in the B/C/S, about
20 two-thirds of the way down, Radivoje says: "We are now trying to
21 establish our authority in the municipality. We shall also appeal to the
22 Muslims, not only Serbs. The army is the product of SDS policy." On to
23 the next page of the translation: "Our goals are well known." And then a
24 comment by another member at the bottom of the page in B/C/S, and on to
25 the next page: "We have achieved now what we dreamt of a year ago.
Page 9986
1 Everything that was done, it was done with one objective in mind."
2 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, could we know, if the witness can help
3 on this, whether the underlining in the B/C/S was in the original or -- I
4 don't know. I suppose question number 1 is whether Ms. Hanson has seen
5 the original, whether it's in the copy, or just something about the
6 underlining.
7 THE WITNESS: I have not handled the originals of this ERN, so I
8 can't say. But the way it is produced here, it is there -- it appears to
9 be there in this original handwritten version. This ERN is, I believe,
10 the actual originals. But I can confirm that by going to the vault, sir.
11 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. Well, if you have no more information at this
12 moment, we'll have to look at that. I don't know how important the
13 underlined points are, or what it specifically would mean, but let's see.
14 Please proceed, Mr. Hannis.
15 MR. HANNIS:
16 Q. Next is tab 307 in the presentation, master tab 444, from the 7th
17 of May meeting.
18 A. The Crisis --
19 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Excuse me, I have a question. I
20 would like to ask the witness how to understand what that sentence on page
21 2, which is "we shall appeal." I didn't really understand what you said
22 exactly, and I didn't follow. "We shall appeal to the Muslims." At the
23 bottom of page 2, "we are now trying to establish an authority in the
24 municipality. We shall also appeal to the Muslims, not only to the
25 Serbs."
Page 9987
1 THE WITNESS: Yes, "appeal" in the sense of win over. "We are
2 going to call ourselves the municipal authority, and we shall try to win
3 the Muslims over, not just the Serbs." Is that a clear enough ...
4 JUDGE HANOTEAU: [Interpretation] Thank you, witness.
5 MR. HANNIS:
6 Q. Now, do you have 307 in front of you?
7 A. Yes, 307, the bottom of the page in the translation, at the top of
8 page 02276157, an interesting indication of links to the republican level,
9 where Radivoje, as president of the Crisis Staff, says that "Djeric has
10 promised to send instructions for the organisation of the administrative
11 organs," et cetera. I would note that this is about ten days after
12 Djeric's instructions on the operations of Crisis Staffs were issued. So
13 whether it's reference to that or other instructions of which I do not
14 know, it is nonetheless indicative of look into the republican level for
15 instructions as they've set up their municipalities.
16 Q. Next, may I show you presentation tab 308, master tab 229, from
17 the 9th of May, 1992.
18 A. Here, notable are the military preparations and the relations with
19 the TO, because by now, the Crisis Staff has set up a TO command in
20 Trnovo. And we see from the minutes, some - what Subotic called minor
21 disagreements - some disagreements on actions to be taken, and Radivoje,
22 as president of the Crisis Staff, sets out at the beginning of the meeting
23 that "the command must obey and execute its tasks." Again, asserting his
24 authority -- the Crisis Staff authority over the TO command.
25 Then in his next speech, on the same page, he notes that they're
Page 9988
1 expecting a transport from the army and the contents should be put in
2 storage.
3 On the next page in the B/C/S, same page in the translation, Glisa
4 suggests bringing up two self- -- I'm sorry, it's Radivoje, still on the
5 same page. Radivoje, on the same page, suggests bringing up two
6 self-propelled guns. And then on the last page, the second page in the
7 B/C/S, Radivoje says that "Glisa should go to General Djordjevic today to
8 procure the two HUMVEEs," so the combat vehicles. We should constitute
9 our organs in Trnovo. So a combination of military preparations and
10 forming their own municipal organs are discussed at the Crisis Staff.
11 Q. Thank you. Next is presentation tab 309, master tab 449. It's a
12 list dated the 10th of May, 1992 of members of the Crisis Staff?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. Can you tell us who are -- what organs those people belong to?
15 A. They are all members of the SDS municipal board.
16 Q. And what agencies were they from, if you know?
17 A. I don't.
18 Q. Were any of them military or police? If you recall at the moment.
19 A. I know from my analysis that one was a member of the police, but
20 at this moment, without my notes, I can't say which one. So I don't -- I
21 won't say which.
22 Q. Then let me show you next presentation tab 310, master tab 435,
23 from the 11th of May.
24 A. Another long session with some interesting comments, and
25 indicative of some disagreement between the TO command and the Crisis
Page 9989
1 Staff, because Danilo Golijanin, listed here as one of the attendees, was
2 the head of the TO command for Trnovo. He attends the Crisis Staff
3 meetings, and the head of the Crisis Staff attends the TO command
4 meetings, indicating the overlap and the communication.
5 Here at the -- on page 1 in the translation, and in the B/C/S, at
6 the bottom of page 02276170, Radivoje says: "Tomorrow, we will provide
7 the army with food from Kalinovik. The mobilisation should be carried out
8 via courier on the list and getting mobilisation papers from Ilidza," so
9 discussion about mobilisation.
10 Then in Radivoje's next speech, still on page 1 in the
11 translation, and on page 02276171, in the middle of the page: "War is
12 unavoidable in Trnovo."
13 On the next page in the translation, same page in B/C/S, the head
14 of the TO command says -- the translation -- apparently, the revised
15 translation hasn't gotten into the binders, so I will read what he says in
16 B/C/S.
17 [No interpretation].
18 THE INTERPRETER: Sorry, the channel was wrong. The translation
19 was: "I will not give the order to bomb without serious provocation."
20 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, thank you.
21 A. And then Radivoje responds, "Well, in that case, we might as well
22 just tell the SDA we're going to surrender all our weapons." I take that
23 to be sarcastic. He warns of provocations, and he says -- this is on the
24 next page in the B/C/S, 02276172, he says: "Even though everything is
25 quiet in Trnovo, we will end up living in a Muslim state." So --
Page 9990
1 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, excuse me, I've been trying to attract
2 Ms. Philpott's attention for a couple of minutes, but failing, which is
3 the story of my life, really, but, Your Honour, I have about two minutes'
4 worth of report back. I didn't know whether Your Honour wanted, on the
5 items from the housekeeping day, whether Your Honour wanted to deal with
6 them today. It could be first thing Monday morning. I'm entirely in Your
7 Honours' hands on that.
8 JUDGE ORIE: For several reasons, I have also a list on those
9 issues on which a report would be received in two days, which ones would
10 be dealt with by the end of the week. My problem is it would easily take
11 us a little bit of extra time, and since my next hearing starts at a
12 quarter past two, I would rather leave it until Monday.
13 MR. STEWART: I'm entirely in Your Honour's hands. No problem at
14 all.
15 JUDGE ORIE: Thank you. Whatever was said about reporting at the
16 end of this week will then be the beginning of next week.
17 MR. STEWART: We're grateful for the extension, Your Honour.
18 Thank you.
19 MR. HANNIS: Thank you, Your Honour.
20 Q. I would like to go to presentation tab 311, which is master tab
21 440. This is from a meeting of the TO command on 15 May 1992.
22 A. As I mentioned, there was overlap of personality and sharing of
23 information between the Crisis Staff and the TO command. We note that
24 Glisa Simanic is present, and that the commander of the staff informed the
25 present parties about the SDS staff conclusions, and lists the conclusions
Page 9991
1 and positions of the SDS Crisis Staff.
2 On the second page of the translation, in the B/C/S the next page,
3 00949423, also an indication of viewing themselves as part of the
4 Republika Srpska or the -- the Bosnian Serb state. The commander is
5 informed of the order of the SRBH on matters of discipline and
6 disobedience, and the command concludes that "any violation should be
7 reported to the official authorities of the SDS." So the TO command
8 expects the SDS to enforce the regulations of the Serbian Republic.
9 Q. Thank you.
10 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, the next document is one that has, I
11 think, several items we want to discuss. I see it's about three minutes
12 till. I know you directed me to finish my direct today but I've run a
13 little bit short. I have about 20 documents left. I would request the
14 opportunity to finish in half an hour or 45 minutes on Monday.
15 JUDGE ORIE: I'll consider it, Mr. Hannis. On the other hand,
16 what we're doing now where we, I would say, went through the material
17 subject by subject, now we do it municipality by municipality. We went
18 through one entirely. Of course, the material, and the order in which you
19 presented it, appears in the main material as well, so by reading it in
20 its subsequent order, so the only thing that's added, then, is that it is
21 presented in a different sequence rather than that it's any new material.
22 We'll consider it, but --
23 MR. STEWART: Your Honour, may I make an observation on that?
24 It's only this, Your Honour: That, for example, certainly we can see, on
25 our side, we can see which documents are coming up. What we can't see is
Page 9992
1 which particular bits of the documents are being drawn attention to. We
2 have no particular wish to insist, with respect to Your Honour, that it's
3 done in this way, in open court. On the other hand, we would need to know
4 on the Defence side, very quickly then, what are those passages. So there
5 are other ways of doing that, but simply to throw that batch of documents
6 at us without that steer, that's not so readily manageable.
7 JUDGE ORIE: One of the other ways in dealing with it would be
8 that you indicate by each step -- one way of doing it would be that you
9 make one example of that and say, These are the portions we'd like to
10 highlight, to draw your specific attention to, and then we can read it and
11 then and it's there. Of course, then we miss the comments. But on the
12 other hand --
13 MR. STEWART: I'm sorry, what I had in mind is we would have no
14 problem with that, Your Honour, but could I please ask then to have that
15 by, say, 5.00 today, which is work in a different way. I'm not pressing
16 for this, Your Honour. As far as the Defence is concerned, we're in Your
17 Honours' hands. We're not pressing for this. We have no problem with
18 Mr. Hannis simply proceeding in the conventional way and completing his
19 examination-in-chief. That is, in principle, the preferable course.
20 [Trial Chamber confers]
21 MR. HANNIS: Your Honour, if I may make one last comment --
22 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, Mr. Hannis.
23 MR. HANNIS: -- in terms of appeal. Of the remaining 21 or 22
24 documents, I think eight or nine of them are new, were not footnoted to
25 her documents, so they're items we haven't seen before. In addition, we
Page 9993
1 did lose half an hour at the beginning of today and --
2 JUDGE ORIE: Yes, I know that, but that's, of course, a bit
3 included, because you said you would not need perhaps the last one hour
4 and a half, so altogether -- Mr. Hannis, you're invited to provide Mr.
5 Stewart with a copy of the last materials, indicating, if it's only
6 briefly, but by perhaps marking with the yellow marker, the areas you'd
7 like to draw specific attention to. At a later stage, the Chamber might
8 give you an opportunity, if there are really matters of great concern,
9 because most of what we hear now is illustration rather than anything new,
10 but if there's anything that would need very specific attention, but not
11 going through the material as we did now, then you may apply for
12 permission to do so. If you would provide Mr. Stewart with the -- well,
13 the last documents with the highlights, then the Chamber, at a later
14 stage, would like to receive at least one highlighted version as well so
15 that we can work that in our material and are well prepared for
16 cross-examination next week.
17 MR. HANNIS: Would I be permitted to address the new documents
18 that are not in her report on Monday morning?
19 JUDGE ORIE: What do you mean by new? Because I see there are two
20 kinds of documents. The one is for presentation only, but they are in the
21 original material, because there's usually -- there usually is a reference
22 to the master tab. So to that extent, they are new to the extent that we
23 have not spoken about it in court, but they're not new -- yes?
24 MR. HANNIS: I'm sorry, Your Honour, the master tabs include new
25 material.
Page 9994
1 JUDGE ORIE: Yes.
2 MR. HANNIS: Master tabs don't include only the footnoted
3 documents to her report. So if it says "presentation only," as I
4 understand it, those are items that were not in her report and we're not
5 familiar with, so they are brand new.
6 JUDGE ORIE: But I take it they are used as the basis for your
7 research, even if you made no specific reference to some of them.
8 THE WITNESS: Some of the documents that are "presentation only"
9 have come to my attention only after writing the report.
10 JUDGE ORIE: Yes. You may mark those documents that are, to that
11 extent, new, that they have not been taken into consideration by you when
12 you wrote your report. If you are not aware of which documents those
13 exactly are, then Ms. Hanson is permitted to provide the relevant
14 information to you so that you can make up that list.
15 MR. HANNIS: I think I can tell from our list here.
16 JUDGE ORIE: Okay.
17 MR. HANNIS: Thank you.
18 JUDGE ORIE: Then we will adjourn. I indicated until now the
19 Prosecution has taken, thus far, some 12 hours and 15 minutes,
20 approximately, in examination-in-chief.
21 Madam Registrar, next week we will sit in this same courtroom?
22 And 9.00. We will adjourn until Monday, at 9.00.
23 And, Ms. Hanson, apart from the exception I just gave to you,
24 although not needed, you will receive the same instructions as I gave you
25 before.
Page 9995
1 --- Whereupon the hearing adjourned at 1.50 p.m.,
2 to be reconvened on Monday, the 7th day of March,
3 2005, at 9.00 a.m.
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25