CASE NO. IT-02-58-PT
The Prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, pursuant to her authority under Article 18 of the Statute of the Tribunal, charges:
with GENOCIDE; CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT GENOCIDE;
Murder, Persecutions, Forcible Transfer and Inhumane Acts as
CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY; and Murder as a VIOLATION OF THE LAWS
OR CUSTOMS OF WAR, as set forth herein:
- LJUBISA BEARA, son of Jovan, was born on 14 July
1939 in Sarajevo. In May 1992, he was appointed Chief of Security
of the Army of Republika Srpska (VRS) Main Staff. He served
in that position at all times relevant to this Amended Indictment.
SUPERIOR AUTHORITY / POSITION OF THE ACCUSED
- During the VRS attack on the Srebrenica enclave and the
subsequent killings and executions of Bosnian Muslim men,
LJUBISA BEARA was a Colonel and was the Chief of Security
of the Main Staff of the VRS. He was present in the areas
of Bratunac and Zvornik from 13 July to 16 July 1995.
- As Chief of Security, LJUBISA BEARA’s responsibilities,
as vested in him by his commander and Commander of the VRS,
Ratko Mladic, and as defined by the Yugoslav People’s Army
(JNA) security regulations adopted by the VRS, were to monitor
enemy activities within and against VRS units and to propose
measures to his superiors to counter security threats posed
by the enemy. This function included identifying traitors
or other security threats inside VRS units, as well as dealing
with enemy threats from outside the VRS, such as sabotage,
surveillance, and intervention activities of the enemy. He
was responsible for managing the Main Staff units of the Military
Police and proposing ways to utilise the Military Police.
He was also responsible, in general, for co-ordinating with
the bodies of the MUP (Ministry of the Interior) in the six
VRS Corps zones of responsibility. LJUBISA BEARA likewise
was responsible for dealing with captured Bosnian Muslim
prisoners from Srebrenica from 11 July 1995 until 1 November
1995.
GENERAL ALLEGATIONS
- At all times relevant to this Amended Indictment, a state
of armed conflict existed in the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
- At all relevant times, the accused was required to abide
by the laws and customs governing the conduct of war.
- All acts and omissions charged as crimes against humanity
were part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against
the Bosnian Muslim civilian population of Srebrenica and its
surroundings.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
- On 12 May 1992, Momcilo Krajisnik, President of the RS National
Assembly executed the following "DECISION ON STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES
OF THE SERBIAN PEOPLE IN BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA," which was
published in the Official Gazette of the Republika Srpska
on 26 November 1993:
"The strategic objectives or priorities of the Serbian
people in Bosnia and Herzegovina are to:
- Establish State borders separating the Serbian people
from the other two ethnic communities.
- Set up a corridor between Semberija and Krajina.
- Establish a corridor in the Drina river valley, that is,
eliminate the Drina as a border separating Serbian States.
- Establish a border on the Una and Neretva rivers.
- Divide the city of Sarajevo into Serbian and Bosnian Muslim
parts and establish effective State authorities in both
parts.
- Ensure access to the sea for Republika Srpska."
- After armed conflict erupted in the Republic of Bosnia and
Herzegovina (BiH) in the spring of 1992, Bosnian Serb military
and paramilitary forces attacked and occupied cities, towns,
and villages, including Zvornik, in the eastern part of the
country and participated in an ethnic cleansing campaign that
resulted in an exodus of Bosnian Muslim civilians to enclaves
in Srebrenica, Gorazde, and Zepa.
- On 19 November 1992, General Ratko Mladic issued Operational
Directive 04. This Directive, in part, ordered the Drina Corps
to "inflict the heaviest possible losses on the enemy, and
force him to leave the Birac, Zepa and Gorazde areas together
with the Bosnian Muslim population. First, offer the able-bodied
and armed men to surrender, and if they refuse, destroy them."
- On 16 April 1993, the Security Council of the United Nations,
acting pursuant to Chapter VII of its Charter, adopted Resolution
819, in which it demanded that all parties to the conflict
in the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina treat Srebrenica
and its surroundings as a "safe area," which was to be free
from any armed attack or any other hostile act.
- On 4 July 1994, Lieutenant Colonel Slavko Ognjenovic, then
Commander of the Bratunac Brigade, issued a report to all
members of the Bratunac Brigade stating in relevant part:
"We must continue to arm, train, discipline, and prepare the
RS Army for the execution of this crucial task — the expulsion
of Muslims from the Srebrenica enclave. There will be no retreat
when it comes to the Srebrenica enclave, we must advance.
The enemy’s life has to be made unbearable and their temporary
stay in the enclave impossible so that they leave the enclave
en masse as soon as possible, realising that they cannot
survive there."
- On 8 March 1995, the Supreme Command of the Armed Forces
of the Republika Srpska issued Operational Directive 07. In
this Directive, Republika Srpska President Radovan Karadzic
directed the VRS (specifically the VRS Drina Corps) to "complete
the physical separation of the Srebrenica and Zepa enclaves
as soon as possible, preventing even communication between
individuals between the two enclaves. By planned and well-thought-out
combat operations, create an unbearable situation of total
insecurity, with no hope of further survival or life for the
inhabitants of Srebrenica or Zepa."
- On 2 July 1995, in the Drina Corps operational order for
the attack on the Srebrenica enclave, General Milenko Zivanovic
ordered that the attack of the enclave should result in "reducing
the enclave to its urban area." The size of the enclave on
2 July 1995 was approximately 58 square kilometres and the
urban area of the enclave was about two (2) square kilometres.
Large numbers of the Bosnian Muslim population of the enclave
lived outside the urban area of Srebrenica prior to 2 July
1995.
- On or about 6 July 1995, units of the Drina Corps shelled
Srebrenica and attacked Dutch-manned United Nations observation
posts, which were located in the enclave. The Drina Corps
attack on the Srebrenica enclave, including the shelling,
continued through 11 July 1995, when forces from the Zvornik
Brigade’s Drina Wolves, the Bratunac Brigade, the 10th
Sabotage Detachment and other units of the VRS entered Srebrenica.
- In the several days following this attack on Srebrenica,
VRS forces captured, detained, forcibly transferred, summarily
executed, and buried over 7000 Bosnian Muslim men and boys
from the Srebrenica enclave and forcibly transferred the Bosnian
Muslim women and children of Srebrenica out of the enclave.
The details of these events and the role of the accused therein
are presented in the paragraphs below.
INDIVIDUAL CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY
Direct Criminal Responsibility
- Pursuant to Article 7(1) of the Statute of the Tribunal,
LJUBISA BEARA is individually responsible for Genocide,
Conspiracy to Commit Genocide, Crimes Against Humanity (Murder,
Persecutions, Forcible Transfer, and Inhumane Acts), and Murder
as a Violation of the Laws or Customs of War. LJUBISA BEARA
committed, planned, instigated, ordered, and otherwise aided
and abetted in the planning, preparation, and execution of
these charged crimes. By using the word "committed" in this
Amended Indictment, the Prosecutor does not intend to suggest
that the accused necessarily physically and personally perpetrated
any of the crimes charged. "Committing" the crimes can be
accomplished by virtue of participation in the Joint Criminal
Enterprise.
Joint Criminal Enterprise
- LJUBISA BEARA, together with other VRS and MUP officers
and units as identified in this Amended Indictment, was a
member of and knowingly participated in a Joint Criminal Enterprise,
the common purpose of which was to forcibly transfer the women
and children from the Srebrenica enclave to Kladanj on 12
July and 13 July 1995 and to capture, detain, forcibly transfer,
summarily execute by firing squad, bury, and rebury thousands
of Bosnian Muslim men and boys aged 16 to 60 from the Srebrenica
enclave from 12 July 1995 until about 19 July 1995. The last
known primary burial of Srebrenica victims occurred on or
about 19 July 1995 in Glogova. The initial plan was to forcibly
transfer and summarily execute more than 1000 Bosnian Muslim
men and boys, aged 16 to 60, who were separated from the group
of Bosnian Muslims in Potocari on 12 and 13 July. On 12 July,
this plan was broadened to include the forcible transfer and
summary execution of over 6000 men and boys, aged 16 to 60,
who were captured from the column of Bosnian Muslim men escaping
the Srebrenica enclave from 12 July through about 19 July
1995. Most of these men and boys from the column were captured
along the Bratunac/Milici road on 13 July 1995. Although the
Joint Criminal Enterprise contemplated organised and systematic
executions, it was foreseeable to LJUBISA BEARA that
opportunistic criminal acts, such as those described in this
Amended Indictment, would be carried out by VRS and MUP forces
during and after the Joint Criminal Enterprise. VRS and MUP
forces carried out such opportunistic criminal acts from 12
July 1995 to about 1 November 1995. The implementation of
this Joint Criminal Enterprise resulted in the summary execution
of over 7000 Bosnian Muslim men and boys from the Srebrenica
enclave.
- LJUBISA BEARA possessed the criminal intent and state
of mind required to commit the individual crimes charged in
the Amended Indictment, and his acts significantly assisted
and facilitated the commission of the crimes. The participation
of the accused in the Joint Criminal Enterprise and the specific
acts and responsibilities described in this Amended Indictment
satisfy the elements required for a finding that, pursuant
to Article 7(1) of the Statute of the Tribunal, LJUBISA
BEARA "committed," "planned," "instigated," "ordered,"
and otherwise "aided and abetted" genocide, crimes against
humanity (including murder, persecutions, forcible transfer,
and inhumane acts), and murder as a violation of the laws
or customs of war. These specific acts and responsibilities
of LJUBISA BEARA pursuant to this Joint Criminal Enterprise
are described in the Amended Indictment in paragraphs 17 and
19-36.
- The Joint Criminal Enterprise, of which LJUBISA BEARA
was a member and a key participant, was conceived and designed
by General Ratko Mladic and others on 11 and 12 July 1995,
and administered and carried out by members of the VRS and
MUP forces throughout the time period by the means alleged
in this Amended Indictment.
- Members of this Joint Criminal Enterprise included: General
Ratko Mladic, the Commander of the VRS, General Milenko Zivanovic,
Commander of the Drina Corps through about 2000 hours on 13
July 1995; General Radislav Krstic, Chief of Staff/Deputy
Commander through about 2000 hours on 13 July 1995 and, thereafter,
Commander of the Drina Corps; Colonel Vidoje Blagojevic, Commander
of the Bratunac Brigade; Colonel Vinko Pandurevic, Commander
of the Zvornik Brigade; Lieutenant Colonel Dragan Obrenovic,
Deputy Commander and Chief of Staff of the Zvornik Brigade;
LJUBISA BEARA, Chief of Security of the Main Staff;
Dragan Jokic, Chief of Engineering of the Zvornik Brigade.
Various other individuals and military and police units were
involved in the operation to forcibly transfer and/or murder
the Muslim men and boys, including but not limited to the
following:
Drina Corps Units
Elements of the Bratunac Brigade
Elements of the Zvornik Brigade
Elements of the Vlasenica Brigade
Elements of the 5th Engineering Battalion
Main Staff Units
Elements of the 10th Sabotage Detachment
Elements of the 65th Protection Regiment
MUP Units
Elements of the Republika Srpska "Special
Police"
Elements of the Bratunac Municipal Police
Elements of the Milici Municipal Police
Elements of the Zvornik Municipal Police
As Chief of Security for the Main Staff, LJUBISA BEARA
was directly subordinate to the Assistant Commander for Security
and Intelligence Affairs, who in turn was directly subordinate
to General Ratko Mladic, Commander of the Main Staff of the
VRS. A detailed summary of the military structure of the VRS
is affixed to this Amended Indictment as Annex A.
On 11 July, 1995, four units of the Ministry of the Interior
(MUP) were placed under the command of the VRS.
- These allegations concerning individual criminal responsibility,
including those cited in the Joint Criminal Enterprise paragraphs,
are realleged and incorporated into each of the charges set
forth below.
CHARGES
COUNT 1
(Genocide)
By his acts and omissions described in the paragraphs below,
LJUBISA BEARA committed:
COUNT 1: Genocide, punishable under Articles 4(3)(a)
and 7(1) of the Statute of the Tribunal;
- Between 11 July 1995 and 1 November 1995, LJUBISA BEARA,
with intent to destroy a part of the Bosnian Muslim people
as a national, ethnical, or religious group:
- killed members of the group by summary execution as described
in paragraphs 17 and 28-36; and,
- caused serious bodily or mental harm to members of the
group.
- Immediately after the fall of Srebrenica on 11 July 1995,
senior VRS officers including Ratko Mladic and Radislav Krstic
surveyed the town. At this time, Ratko Mladic announced that
"the moment has finally come for us to take revenge upon the
Turks here."
- Thousands of Bosnian Muslims from the enclave, including
women, children, and some men, fled to the UN Compound in
Potocari on 11 July 1995, where they sought the protection
of the UN Dutch battalion (Dutchbat). Meanwhile, approximately
15,000 Bosnian Muslim men from the enclave, with some women
and children, gathered at the villages of Susnjari and Jaglici
during the evening of 11 July 1995 and fled in a huge column
through the woods towards Tuzla. Approximately one third of
this group consisted of armed Bosnian Muslim military personnel.
The rest were civilians and unarmed military personnel.
- On the evening of 11 July and the morning of 12 July, three
critical meetings concerning the fate of the refugees who
had fled to Potocari took place at the Hotel Fontana in Bratunac.
At the first meeting, held at approximately 2000 hours on
11 July, Ratko Mladic met with other members of the VRS and
with the Dutchbat command. Ratko Mladic intimidated and threatened
the Dutchbat commander. Ratko Mladic, Radislav Krstic, and
other members of the VRS convened the second meeting at approximately
2300 hours on 11 July. Members of the Dutchbat command and
representatives of the Bosnian Muslim refugees at Potocari
attended the meeting. At this second meeting, Ratko Mladic
warned the Bosnian Muslim representatives that their people
could either "survive or disappear." Ratko Mladic, Radislav
Krstic, and other VRS and Bosnian Serb civilian representatives
convened a third meeting at about 1000 hours on 12 July 1995.
Dutchbat officers and representatives of the Bosnian Muslim
refugees also attended this meeting. At this meeting, Ratko
Mladic explained that he would supervise the "evacuation"
of refugees from Potocari and that he wanted to see all military-aged
Bosnian Muslim men so that they could be screened as possible
war criminals. During the evening of 11 July and into the
early morning of 12 July 1995, the plan to transport the civilian
refugee population from Potocari was developed.
- This Bosnian Muslim refugee population remained in and around
Potocari from 11 July until 13 July 1995. Throughout this
time, members of the VRS and the MUP terrorised them.
- On or about 12 July 1995, in the presence of Ratko Mladic,
Radislav Krstic, and others, approximately 50 to 60 buses
and trucks arrived near the UN military compound in Potocari.
Shortly after the arrival of these vehicles, the forcible
transfer process of Bosnian Muslim women and children began.
As the Bosnian Muslim women, children, and men started to
board the buses and trucks, VRS and/or MUP soldiers separated
over 1000 Bosnian Muslim men from the women and children and
forcibly transported these men to temporary detention sites
in Bratunac on 12 and 13 July 1995.
- Beginning around 12 July 1995 and continuing throughout
the period of organised executions, members of the VRS and
the MUP confiscated and destroyed personal property and effects
belonging to the Bosnian Muslim male prisoners, including
their identification documents and valuables. This confiscation
and destruction of personal property and effects occurred
in Potocari, at various points of capture and collection along
the Bratunac/Milici road, and at various execution sites.
In addition, the prisoners in Potocari and in Bratunac were
not provided with food or medical treatment, nor with any
meaningful rations of water, during their days in detention
pending execution. On 13 July 1995, LJUBISA BEARA was
present along the Bratunac/Milici road. He was involved in
and issued orders relating to the capture, detention, and
forcible transport of Bosnian Muslim prisoners along the Bratunac/Milici
road.
- VRS and MUP officers and soldiers committed a number of
opportunistic killings of the Bosnian Muslims in Potocari
on 12 and 13 July 1995. Such opportunistic killings occurred
as a natural and foreseeable consequence of the unfolding
Joint Criminal Enterprise. These Bosnian Muslims were taken
prisoner in Potocari before being killed. LJUBISA BEARA,
as Chief of Security charged with the handling of prisoners
and by virtue of the authority vested in him by his commander,
had responsibility for them. The opportunistic killings in
Potocari resulted in the following:
- On 12 July, the bodies of nine Bosnian Muslim men who
had been shot, were found in the woods near the UN Compound
on the Budak side of the main road.
- On 12 July, the bodies of nine or ten Bosnian Muslim males
were found about seven hundred metres from the UN Compound
behind the White House in a creek.
- On the morning of the 13 July, the bodies of six Bosnian
Muslim women and five Bosnian Muslim men were found in a
stream near the UN Compound in Potocari.
- On 13 July, one Bosnian Muslim man was taken behind a
building near the "White House" and summarily executed.
- Between 12 July and about 17 July 1995, approximately 6000
Bosnian Muslim men from the column of men escaping the Srebrenica
enclave were captured by or surrendered to VRS and MUP forces.
On 13 July 1995, LJUBISA BEARA was present along the
Bratunac/Milici road. He was involved in and issued orders
relating to the capture, detention, and transport of Bosnian
Muslim prisoners along the Bratunac/Milici road. Apart from
those transported directly to execution sites, the prisoners
captured from the column on 13 July 1995 were taken to the
same temporary detention sites in and around Bratunac as those
men separated from Potocari.
- VRS and MUP officers and soldiers committed a number of
opportunistic killings of Bosnian Muslim prisoners temporarily
detained in Bratunac in schools, buildings, and vehicles parked
along the road. Such opportunistic killings occurred as a
natural and foreseeable consequence of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise to forcibly transfer the Muslim women, children
and men of Srebrenica and to execute the Muslim men of Srebrenica.
As Chief of Security charged with the handling of prisoners
and by virtue of the authority vested in him by his commander,
LJUBISA BEARA had responsibility for these Bosnian Muslim
prisoners. These opportunistic killings occurred between 12
July and about 15 July 1995 in several different locations
in Bratunac, namely:
- On 12 July, beginning at approximately 2200 hours and
continuing through 13 July, more than 50 Bosnian Muslim
men were taken from a hangar behind the Vuk Karadzic elementary
school in Bratunac and summarily executed.
- On 13 July, at approximately 2130 hours, two Bosnian Muslim
men were taken off a truck in Bratunac town, taken to a
nearby garage, and summarily executed.
- On 13 July, in the evening, a Bosnian Muslim man who was
mentally retarded was taken off a bus parked in front of
the Vuk Karadzic elementary school in Bratunac and summarily
executed.
- DELETED
- DELETED
- Between the evening of 13 July and the morning of 15 July,
Bosnian Muslim males were frequently and consistently taken
from the Vuk Karadzic elementary school and summarily executed.
Those Bosnian Muslim prisoners who survived their temporary
detention in Bratunac were transported to the Zvornik area
between 13 and 15 July 1995 for further detention and execution.
- VRS and MUP forces participated in the forcible transfer,
mass execution, and burial of thousands of captured Bosnian
Muslim men from the Srebrenica enclave. This Joint Criminal
Enterprise, designed to rid the area of all Bosnian Muslim
prisoners, took place over a seven-day period from 12 July
until about 19 July 1995. As Chief of Security charged with
the handling of prisoners and by virtue of the authority vested
in him by his commander, LJUBISA BEARA had responsibility
for all of these Bosnian Muslim prisoners, and he assisted
in the implementation and oversight of the murder of these
prisoners. Specifically, on 13 July 1995, LJUBISA BEARA
was present along the Bratunac/Milici road and was responsible
for implementing the transportation plan actively and moving
prisoners to execution sites, including Jadar River, Cerska
Valley and Kravica Warehouse. These acts are further described
in paragraph 17 and paragraphs 22-36 of this Amended Indictment.
This wide-scale and organised killing of Bosnian Muslim men
occurred in several different locations in and around Srebrenica,
Bratunac, and Zvornik as follows:
32.1 Potocari: On 12 July 1995, in between the
Zinc Factory and "Alija’s" house, VRS and/or MUP soldiers
summarily executed by decapitation approximately 80 to 100
Bosnian Muslim men. The bodies were then taken away on a truck.
32.2 Jadar River: At approximately 1100 hours on
13 July 1995, working with individuals and units of the VRS
and/or MUP, a small squad of soldiers consisting of at least
one Bratunac police officer (Bratunac MUP) captured approximately
16 Bosnian Muslim men from the column of men retreating from
the Srebrenica enclave, transported them from Konjevic Polje
to an isolated area on the bank of the Jadar River, and summarily
executed 15 of them. One individual was wounded and managed
to escape.
32.3 Cerska Valley: On 13 July 1995, in the early
afternoon hours, VRS and/or MUP soldiers transported about
150 Bosnian Muslim men to an area along a dirt road in the
Cerska Valley about three (3) kilometres from Konjevic Polje,
summarily executed them and, using heavy equipment, covered
them with dirt.
32.4 Kravica Warehouse: On 13 July 1995, in the
early evening hours, VRS and/or MUP soldiers summarily executed
over 1000 Bosnian Muslim men detained in a large warehouse
in the village of Kravica. The soldiers used automatic weapons,
hand grenades, and other weaponry to kill the Bosnian Muslims
inside the warehouse. On 14 July 1995, heavy equipment arrived
and removed the victims’ bodies to two large mass graves located
in the nearby villages of Glogova and Ravnice.
32.5 Tisca: Throughout the day on 13 July 1995,
VRS and/or MUP soldiers transported Bosnian Muslim women and
children who had been separated from male members of their
families in Potocari to an area near Tisca village. VRS soldiers
from the Vlasenica Brigade of the Drina Corps identified and
separated some remaining Bosnian Muslim men and boys and some
of the Bosnian Muslim women from this group at Tisca, while
the rest of the group was forcibly transferred to Bosnian
Muslim territory. Throughout the day on 13 July 1995, VRS
soldiers forced the selected Bosnian Muslim men and women
to walk to a nearby school, where they were abused and assaulted.
On or about the evening of 13 July 1995 and the day of 14
July 1995, VRS and/or MUP soldiers loaded 25 Bosnian Muslim
men from the school onto a truck, drove them to an isolated
pasture nearby, and summarily executed them with automatic
weapons.
32.6 Orahovac (near Lazete): In the late evening
hours of 13 July and during the day of 14 July 1995, working
together with other individuals and units, personnel from
the Military Police Company of the Bratunac Brigade transported
to the Grbavci School in the village of Orahovac hundreds
of Bosnian Muslim males from in and around Bratunac who had
surrendered or been captured from the column of men retreating
from the Srebrenica enclave or had been separated in Potocari.
On 14 July 1995, VRS personnel, including members of the Military
Police Company of the Zvornik Brigade, guarded and blindfolded
the Bosnian Muslim males detained at the Grbavci School. In
the early afternoon of 14 July 1995, VRS personnel transported
these Bosnian Muslim males from the school at Grbavci to a
nearby field, where personnel, including members of the 4th
Battalion of the Zvornik Brigade, ordered the prisoners off
the trucks and summarily executed them with automatic weapons.
Approximately 1000 Bosnian Muslim males were killed. On 14
and 15 July 1995, members of the Zvornik Brigade Engineering
Company used heavy equipment to bury the victims in mass graves
at the execution site, while the executions continued. On
the evening of 14 July, lights from the engineering machinery
illuminated the execution and burial sites during the executions.
32.7 The Petkovci School: On 14 July 1995, VRS
and/or MUP personnel transported from detention sites in and
around Bratunac to the school at Petkovci approximately 1000
Bosnian Muslim males who had surrendered or been captured
from the column of men retreating from the Srebrenica enclave
or had been separated in Potocari. On 14 July and during the
early morning hours of 15 July 1995, VRS and/or MUP personnel
struck, beat, assaulted, and shot with automatic weapons Bosnian
Muslim males detained at the school.
32.8 The "Dam" near Petkovci: On or about the evening
of 14 July 1995 and the early morning hours of 15 July 1995,
VRS personnel from the Zvornik Brigade, including drivers
and trucks from the 6th Infantry Battalion, transported
the surviving members of the group of approximately 1000 Bosnian
Muslim males from the school at Petkovci to an area below
the Dam near Petkovci. VRS or MUP soldiers assembled them
below the Dam and summarily executed them with automatic weapons.
In the morning of 15 July 1995, working together with other
individuals and units, VRS personnel from the Engineering
Company of the Zvornik Brigade used excavators and other heavy
equipment to bury the victims while the executions continued.
32.9 Pilica School: On or about 14 and 15 July
1995, VRS and/or MUP personnel transported from detention
sites in Bratunac to the school at Pilica approximately 1200
Bosnian Muslim males who had surrendered or been captured
from the column of men retreating from the Srebrenica enclave
or had been separated in Potocari. On or about 14 and 15 July
1995, VRS military personnel with automatic weapons summarily
executed many of the Bosnian Muslim males who were being detained
at the school. On 17 July 1995, VRS personnel from the "R"
Battalion of the Zvornik Brigade retrieved the bodies of the
victims from the Pilica School and transported them to the
Branjevo Military Farm. On 17 July 1995, the Engineering Company
of the Zvornik Brigade buried the victims of the Pilica School
executions in a mass grave at the Branjevo Military Farm.
32.10 Branjevo Military Farm: On the morning of
16 July 1995, VRS personnel transported from the Pilica school
by bus to the Branjevo Military Farm the remaining members
of the group of approximately 1200 Bosnian Muslim males who
had surrendered or been captured from the column of men retreating
from the Srebrenica enclave or had been separated in Potocari.
After the Bosnian Muslim males arrived at the Branjevo Military
Farm, members of the 10th Sabotage Detachment and
the Bratunac Brigade, working together with other individuals
and units, summarily executed them by automatic weapon fire.
On 17 July 1995, working together with other individuals and
units, VRS personnel from the Engineering Company of the Zvornik
Brigade, buried hundreds of victims in a nearby mass grave.
32.11 Pilica Cultural Centre: On 16 July 1995,
VRS personnel from the Bratunac Brigade travelled a short
distance to the village of Pilica and worked with other VRS
and/or MUP personnel to summarily execute, with automatic
weapons, approximately 500 men inside the Pilica Cultural
Centre who had surrendered or been captured from the column
of men retreating from the Srebrenica enclave or had been
separated in Potocari. On 17 July 1995, VRS personnel from
the "R" Battalion of the Zvornik Brigade retrieved the bodies
of the victims from the Pilica Cultural Centre and transported
them to the Branjevo Military Farm. On 17 July 1995, the Engineering
Company of the Zvornik Brigade buried the victims of the Pilica
School executions in a mass grave at the Branjevo Military
Farm.
32.12 Kozluk: On or before 16 July 1995, working
together with other individuals and units, VRS and/or MUP
soldiers, transported to an isolated place near Kozluk, in
the Zvornik Brigade zone of responsibility, and summarily
executed with automatic weapons about 500 Bosnian Muslim males
who had been captured from the column of men retreating from
the Srebrenica enclave or had been separated in Potocari.
On 16 July 1995, working together with other individuals and
units, VRS soldiers from the Engineering Company of the Zvornik
Brigade, buried the victims of the executions in a mass grave
nearby.
- As Chief of Security charged with the handling of prisoners
and by virtue of the authority vested in him by his commander,
LJUBISA BEARA had responsibility for all of these Bosnian
Muslim prisoners, and he assisted in the implementation and
oversight of the forcible transfer and murder of these prisoners.
For instance, on the evening of 14 July 1995, LJUBISA BEARA
was involved in co-ordinating with the Zvornik Brigade headquarters
regarding problems with the prisoners who were being executed
in the Zvornik Brigade area. On the morning of 15 July 1995,
LJUBISA BEARA was still fully engaged in the murder
operation, and he repeatedly requested that he be provided
with additional troops to assist in the execution of thousands
of Bosnian Muslim prisoners.
- During and after the campaign of forcible transfer and organised
executions, the opportunistic killing of captured Bosnian
Muslim men from the Srebrenica enclave by VRS and MUP personnel
continued through about 1 November 1995, as set out below.
These opportunistic killings, which were a natural and foreseeable
consequence of the Joint Criminal Enterprise to forcibly transfer
the population of Srebrenica and to murder all the Muslim
men, occurred in the zones of responsibility of both the Bratunac
Brigade and the Zvornik Brigade. As Chief of Security charged
with the handling of prisoners and by virtue of the authority
vested in him by his commander, LJUBISA BEARA had responsibility
for these Bosnian Muslim prisoners.
Bratunac Brigade Zone
34.1 Nova Kasaba: Sometime between 13 July and
27 July 1995 VRS and/or MUP personnel captured and executed
33 Bosnian Muslim men from the column fleeing the Srebrenica
enclave. At least 26 of the victims were summarily executed
after being placed in two recently dug graves. Twenty-seven
of the 33 men had their hands tied behind their backs when
they were executed. These graves were located near the village
of Nova Kasaba.
34.2 DELETED
34.3 DELETED
34.4 Kravica Market: During the night between 13
July and 14 July near a supermarket in Kravica, a VRS or MUP
soldier placed his rifle barrel into the mouth of a Bosnian
Muslim prisoner and summarily executed the man. Also during
this period, VRS and/or MUP soldiers struck, beat with rifle
butts, and summarily executed Bosnian Muslim prisoners who
had surrendered or been captured from the column of men retreating
from the Srebrenica enclave or had been separated at Potocari
and were detained on trucks near the supermarket.
34.4 Bratunac Brigade: Sometime between 12
July and 1 November 1995, six Bosnian Muslim men from Srebrenica
were captured by MUP forces, turned over to and interrogated
by security personnel from the Bratunac Brigade, and thereafter
summarily executed by unknown persons. The identification
details for these six Bosnian Muslim men are as follows:
(a) Zazif AVDIC, son of Ramo, date of birth: 15 September
1954.
(b) Munib DEDIC, son of Emin, date of birth: 26 April 1956.
(c) Aziz HUSIC, son of Osman, date of birth: 08 April 1966.
(d) Resid SINANOVIC, son of Rahman, date of birth: 15 October
1949.
(e) Mujo HUSIC, son of Osman, date of birth: 27 August 1961.
(f) Hasib IBISEVIC, son of Ibrahim, date of birth: 27 February
1964.
Zvornik Brigade Zone
34.6 Nezuk: On 19 July 1995, VRS personnel from the
16th Brigade of the 1st Krajina Corps,
re-subordinated to the command of the Zvornik Brigade, captured
approximately 10 Bosnian Muslim males from the column and
summarily executed them using automatic weapons at a place
near Nezuk
34.7 Zvornik Brigade: On or about 19 July 1995, the
following four Bosnian Muslim men were captured from the column
by VRS and/or MUP forces in the Zvornik Brigade zone of responsibility
and turned over to Zvornik Brigade Security personnel:
(a) Sakib KIVIRIC, son of Salko, date of birth: 24 June 1964.
(b) Emin MUSTAFIC, son of Rifet, date of birth: 7 October
1969.
(c) Fuad DJOZIC, son of Senusija, date of birth: 2 May 1965.
(d) Almir HALILOVIC, son of Suljo, date of birth: 25 August
1980.
On or about 22 July 1995, these men were interrogated by
Zvornik Brigade personnel and were summarily executed sometime
thereafter by unknown persons working together with the Zvornik
Brigade Security personnel.
34.8 DELETED
- From about 18 July through about 1 November 1995, additional
members of the Bosnian Muslim column were captured or killed
in the Bratunac and Zvornik Brigade zone by VRS and MUP forces.
As Chief of Security charged with the handling of prisoners
and by virtue of the authority vested in him by his commander,
LJUBISA BEARA had responsibility for these Bosnian Muslim
prisoners.
- From about 1 August 1995 through about 1 November 1995,
VRS and MUP personnel participated in an organised and comprehensive
effort to conceal the killings and executions in the Zvornik
and Bratunac Brigade zones of responsibility by reburying
bodies exhumed from initial mass graves at the following locations:
Branjevo Military Farm; Kozluk; the "Dam" near Petkovci; Orahovac;
and Glogova; and transferring them to secondary graves at:
twelve sites along the Cancari Road (containing bodies from
Branjevo Military Farm and Kozluk); four sites near Liplje
(containing bodies from the "Dam" near Petkovci); seven sites
near Hodzici (containing bodies from Orahovac); and seven
sites near Zeleni Jadar (containing bodies from Glogova).
This reburial operation was a natural and foreseeable consequence
of the execution and original burial plan conceived by the
Joint Criminal Enterprise. This operation involved members
of the Main Staff and Drina Corps security organs with responsibility
over the Zvornik Brigade zone, including LJUBISA BEARA.
- The conduct of LJUBISA BEARA met the requisite four
elements of Genocide, namely that:
- The accused killed one or more persons and/or caused serious
bodily or mental harm to one or more persons;
- Such persons belonged to a particular national, ethnical,
racial, or religious group;
- The accused intended to kill the persons and/or cause
them serious bodily or mental harm; and
- The accused committed these acts in furtherance of the
intent to destroy, in whole or in part, that national, ethnical,
racial, or religious group, as such.
COUNT 2
(Conspiracy to Commit Genocide)
COUNT 2: Conspiracy to commit genocide, punishable
under Articles 4(3)(b) and 7(1) of the Statute of the Tribunal.
- LJUBISA BEARA entered an agreement with several others,
including General Ratko Mladic, the Commander of the VRS,
General Milenko Zivanovic, Commander of the Drina Corps through
about 2000 hours on 13 July 1995; General Radislav Krstic,
Chief of Staff/Deputy Commander through about 2000 hours on
13 July 1995 and, thereafter, Commander of the Drina Corps;
Colonel Vujadin Popovic, Assistant Commander for Security
of the Drina Corps, Colonel Vinko Pandurevic, Commander of
the Zvornik Brigade; Lieutenant Drago Nikolic, the Zvornik
Brigade Security Officer, and others, to kill the Muslim men
from Srebrenica separated at Potocari or captured or having
surrendered from the column and others and to cause serious
bodily or mental harm to the Muslims of Srebrenica.
38.1. LJUBISA BEARA entered this agreement with
the intent to kill the Muslim men of Srebrenica and to cause
serious bodily or mental harm to the Muslims of Srebrenica,
and in furtherance of the intent to destroy, in part, that
national, ethnical, racial, or religious group of the Bosnian
Muslims, as such.
38.2. The conduct of LJUBISA BEARA met the requisite
elements of Conspiracy to Commit Genocide, namely that:
a) The accused entered into an agreement between two or more
persons to commit the crime of genocide
b) The accused intended to commit genocide.
In addition, the accused himself committed acts in furtherance
of the conspiracy, including but not limited to the following:
a) On 13 July, the accused helped to organise the detention
of Muslim prisoners from Srebrenica, as reflected in an intercept
recorded at 1009 hours, where the accused directed that Muslim
prisoners be assembled at Nova Kasaba playground;
b) On 13 July, the accused was in and around the town of
Bratunac and organised the detention and transportation of
Muslim prisoners;
c) On or about 13 July, the accused helped to organise the
burials at Glogova;
d) DELETED
e) On or about the afternoon of 14 July, the accused went
to the school at Petkovci where he organised the detention
and murder of Muslim men there;
f) The morning of 15 July, in conversations with General
Zivanovic and General Krstic, the accused requested additional
troops to help execute the Muslims detained in the Zvornik
area;
g) On 16 July, the accused spoke with Colonel Cerovic, a
Drina Corps officer, about the murder of the remaining Muslim
prisoners.
And,
COUNT 3
(Extermination)
By his acts and omissions described in the preceding paragraphs,
LJUBISA BEARA committed:
COUNT 3: Extermination, a CRIME AGAINST
HUMANITY, punishable under Articles 5(b) and 7(1) of the
Statute of the Tribunal.
- The conduct of LJUBISA BEARA met the requisite elements
of Extermination as a Crime Against Humanity, namely that:
a) There was an armed conflict;
b) In a manner relating to a widespread or systematic attack
directed against a civilian population, an act or omission
of the accused or a subordinate caused the death of a person
or persons;
c) The killing of persons was on a massive scale,
d) The accused intended to kill persons on a massive scale
or to create conditions of life that lead to the death of
a large number of people; and
e) The accused had knowledge of the wider context in which
his conduct occurred.
And,
COUNT 4-5
(Murder)
By his acts and omissions described in the preceding paragraphs,
LJUBISA BEARA committed:
COUNT 4: Murder, a CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY,
punishable under Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of the Statute of
the Tribunal.
- The conduct of LJUBISA BEARA met the requisite four
elements of Murder as a Crime Against Humanity, namely that:
a) There was an armed conflict;
b) In a manner related to a widespread or systematic attack
directed against a civilian population, the accused caused
the death of one or more persons;
c) By such conduct, the accused intended to kill or to inflict
serious injury in reckless disregard of human life; and
d) The accused had knowledge of the wider context in which
his conduct occurred.
And,
COUNT 5: Murder, a VIOLATION OF THE LAWS OR
CUSTOMS OF WAR, punishable under Articles 3 and 7(1) of
the Statute of the Tribunal.
- The conduct of LJUBISA BEARA met the requisite four
elements of Murder as a Violation of the Laws or Customs of
War, namely that:
a) There was a nexus between the murder and an armed conflict;
b) The conduct of the accused caused the death of one or
more persons;
c) By such conduct, the accused intended to kill or to inflict
serious injury in reckless disregard of human life; and
d) The victim or victims were persons taking no active part
in the hostilities.
And,
COUNT 6
(Persecutions)
By his acts and omissions alleged in the preceding paragraphs,
LJUBISA BEARA committed:
COUNT 6: Persecutions on political, racial and
religious grounds, a CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY, including
Murder, Cruel and Inhumane Treatment, Terrorising the Civilian
Population, Destruction of Personal Property, and Forcible
Transfer, punishable under Articles 5(h) and 7(1) of the Statute
of the Tribunal.
- The conduct of LJUBISA BEARA met the requisite four
elements of Persecutions as a Crime against humanity, namely
that:
a) There was an armed conflict;
b) In a manner related to a widespread or systematic attack
directed against a civilian population, the accused committed
acts or omissions against a victim or victim population violating
a basic or fundamental human right;
c) The accused’s conduct was committed on political, racial,
or religious grounds, and was committed with requisite discriminatory
intent; and
d) The accused had knowledge of the wider context in which
his conduct occurred.
- As described in this Amended Indictment, the crime of persecutions
was perpetrated, executed, and carried out by and through
the following means:
a) the murder of thousands of Bosnian Muslim civilians,
including men, women, children, and elderly persons;
b) the cruel and inhumane treatment of Bosnian Muslim civilians,
including severe beatings at Potocari and in detention facilities
in Bratunac and Zvornik;
c) the terrorising of Bosnian Muslim civilians in Srebrenica
and at Potocari;
d) the destruction of personal property and effects belonging
to the Bosnian Muslims; and
e) the forcible transfer of Bosnian Muslims from Srebrenica
by means of the forced bussing of the women and children
to Bosnian Muslim-controlled territory and the forced bussing
of the men, separated at Potocari or captured or having
surrendered from the column, up to the Zvornik area, where
they were ultimately executed.
And,
COUNT 7
(Forcible Transfer)
By his acts and omissions described in the preceding paragraphs,
LJUBISA BEARA committed:
COUNT 7: Inhumane Acts (Forcible Transfer), a CRIME
AGAINST HUMANITY, punishable under Articles 5(i) and 7(1)
of the Statute of the Tribunal.
- LJUBISA BEARA helped to organise and coordinate the
forcible transfer of Bosnian Muslims from Srebrenica by means
of the forced bussing of the women and children to Bosnian
Muslim-controlled territory and the forced bussing of the
men, separated at Potocari or captured or having surrendered
from the column, up to the Zvornik area, where they were ultimately
executed.
- The conduct of LJUBISA BEARA met the requisite elements
of Inhumane Acts (Forcible Transfer), as a Crime Against Humanity:
a) There was an armed conflict;
b) In a manner related to a widespread or systematic attack
directed against a civilian population, the accused forcibly
displaced one or more persons without grounds permitted under
international law;
c) The forcible displacement was carried out by expulsion
or other coercive acts;
d) The accused wilfully participated in the forcible displacement
or other coercive acts;
e) The accused acted with the intent that the removal of
the person or persons be permanent; and
f) The accused had knowledge of the wider context in which
his conduct occurred.